An Exploratory Study on Code Smells Detection and Refactoring using LLMs
With the observed progress in machine learning (ML), and particularly the introduction of Large Language Models (LLMs), several activities related to code maintenance could be automated. That includes not only detection and evaluation of design flaws, but also code transformation and refactoring. However, the general-purpose LLMs, while being commonly used and popular, have not been specifically trained for code analysis, and may not be suitable for conducting software maintenance tasks due to biases, and inherent shortcomings of the models. In this paper, we explore if the widely available LLMs could aid the detection and the refactoring of code smells. We focus on four common smells (God Class, Long Method, Feature Envy, and Refused Bequest) and consider five prompts of diverse complexity, asking the model for detecting and removing the identified code smells. Results suggest that general-purpose LLMs cannot be reliably used for that. They can effectively detect or remove code smells only in simple cases, and frequently produce invalid code. However, their performance depends on various factors, e.g., the model, the specific code smell or the prompt objective and composition.