On the Use of SAR Images for Predicting Vegetation Indices: Challenges and Limitations
Optical vegetation and soil indices are widely used in Earth observation, although their estimation is strongly affected by cloud coverage and illumination variability. Synthetic-aperture radar (SAR) has therefore attracted increasing interest as an alternative source for spectral index prediction. Most existing studies focus on directly estimating a single index from SAR observations. In this work, we investigate a more flexible formulation in which Sentinel-2 multispectral bands are first reconstructed from Sentinel-1 SAR data and subsequently used to derive multiple spectral indices. Experiments are conducted on the SEN12TP dataset, exploiting near-synchronous paired Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 acquisitions together with auxiliary elevation and land-cover information. Three SAR-to-multispectral reconstruction strategies are compared, namely, Efficient-UNet, Pix2Pix, and a conditional flow matching model. The resulting indices are then evaluated against those obtained through dedicated index-specific reconstruction models. The results show that Efficient-UNet achieves the best overall multispectral reconstruction performance among the evaluated architectures. Moreover, indices derived from reconstructed multispectral bands achieve performance comparable to dedicated index-specific models while offering substantially greater flexibility, as multiple indices can be computed within a single framework without retraining task-specific models. At the same time, the experiments highlight important intrinsic limitations of SAR-based spectral reconstruction. Although the reconstructed products preserve the large-scale spatial organization of the scenes, they do not fully recover fine spectral and vegetation-sensitive details. Consequently, SAR-derived spectral indices should be regarded as approximate proxies of optical observations rather than direct substitutes, particularly in applications requiring accurate biophysical interpretation.