Cleft Alveolar Bone Grafting Using Mandibular Symphyseal Bone Graft and Resorbable Collagen Membrane: A CBCT-Based 3-Dimensional Morphometric Analysis.
Aug 2026· The Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Journal· pp.
10556656261476579
· 0 citations· 35 references
Medicine
TL;DR
Mandibular symphyseal bone grafting combined with a double-layer resorbable collagen membrane yielded favorable radiographic outcomes, with substantial reduction of alveolar cleft defects and satisfactory bone bridge formation in this retrospective cohort.
Abstract
ObjectiveIliac cancellous bone graft has been regarded as the gold standard for secondary alveolar bone grafting (SABG); however, it is associated with a high resorption rate and donor-site morbidity. This study aimed to evaluate the radiographic outcomes of SABG using a mandibular symphyseal bone graft combined with a double-layer resorbable collagen membrane through standardized 3-dimensional cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT)-based morphometric assessment.DesignRetrospective study.SettingPatients with unilateral cleft lip/palate (UCLP) or bilateral CL/P (BCLP) who underwent SABG at a single center.Patients and InterventionEighteen patients with UCLP/BCLP who underwent SABG using a mandibular symphyseal bone graft and a double-layer resorbable collagen membrane between 2022 and 2025.Main Outcome MeasuresPreoperative and 1.5-year postoperative CBCT-based 3-dimensional linear morphometric measurements, including cleft width reduction and postoperative bone bridge thickness.ResultsAt 1.5 years postoperatively, cleft width significantly reduced at all measurement levels (P < .001). The mean postoperative bone bridge thickness was 5.97 ± 2.02 mm at the mid-root level and 6.62 ± 2.50 mm at the apical level.ConclusionsMandibular symphyseal bone grafting combined with a double-layer resorbable collagen membrane yielded favorable radiographic outcomes, with substantial reduction of alveolar cleft defects and satisfactory bone bridge formation in this retrospective cohort. This technique may be a viable treatment option for selected patients. However, prospective controlled studies with larger cohorts and longer follow-up are needed to confirm its comparative effectiveness and long-term stability.
BackgroundSecondary alveolar bone grafting (SABG) is essential for correcting alveolar defects in patients with cleft lip and palate. While clinical evaluation combined with 2-dimensional (2D) radiography is a practical and cost-effective method for assessing surgical success, inadequate grafting outcomes often necessitate repeat surgeries.ObjectiveTo evaluate the clinical variables influencing SABG outcomes in cleft patients using 2D radiographic images.Materials and MethodsThis retrospective study reviewed data from 63 patients who underwent SABG at the Faculty of Dentistry, Prince of Songkla university between 2013 and 2023. Variables analyzed included age, cleft type/size, surgical techniques, graft materials, and orthodontic timing. Efficacy was assessed via 2D radiographs (18 conventional, 45 digital) using the Chelsea scale for bone bridging and ImageJ software for bone density. Statistical analyses involved Chi-square tests and multiple logistic regression (P < 0.05).ResultsOverall analysis revealed that patient age and cleft type were the only significant predictors of SABG success, with odds ratios of 10.46 and 5.19, respectively. Subgroup analyses indicated that the timing of post-surgical orthodontic movement was the most significant factor in the conventional radiography group, whereas cleft type was the primary determinant in the digital group.ConclusionPatient age and cleft type significantly impact SABG outcomes. Patients aged 10-12 years and those with unilateral cleft deformities exhibit significantly higher success rates compared to other age groups and bilateral deformities.
D. Supakanjanakanti, Wasinee Khetphan, T. Witeerungrot et al.· The Cleft Palate-Craniofacia...· 0 citations
Objectives: This thesis aimed (1) to develop and validate a standardized AI-based 3D workflow for the assessment of alveolar bone grafting (ABG) outcomes and mandibular symphysis (MS) donor-site bone regeneration, and (2) to apply the validated methodology to evaluate the effect of leukocyte-platelet-rich fibrin on alveolar grafting performed with iliac crest (IC) and MS bone. Materials and Methods: Two sequential studies were conducted. First, an AI-powered 3D imaging workflow using automated orientation, segmentation, voxel-based superimposition, and shape correspondence analysis was developed and validated in a sample of 21 patients with cleft lip and alveolus. This workflow was used to assess ABG performed with MS bone, evaluating bone formation at the cleft site and MS donor site bone regeneration. Subsequently, the validated workflow was refined to include volumetric bone quantification and applied in a prospective cohort study of 92 patients with unilateral complete cleft lip and palate who underwent ABG. Patients were allocated in groups according to graft donor site (IC or MS) and the use of L-PRF (with or without). CBCT scans were obtained preoperatively and at a 12-month follow-up. Volumes of maxillary bone formation and MS donor site bone regeneration were assessed using the CBCT scans and 3D models. Shape correspondence analysis was applied to compare pre-and post-harvesting symphyseal morphology. Results: The AI-powered 3D workflow demonstrated feasibility, reproducibility, and clinical applicability for the assessment of ABG outcomes and MS donor site bone regeneration. Volumetric bone formation does not differ significantly regardless to graft source or L-PRF use. No significant main effects of graft type (IC vs MS) or L-PRF use were observed, and no significant interaction between these factors was detected (P > 0.05). MS donor site bone regeneration was high, with a mean regeneration of 92.5 ± 4.8%. Shape correspondence analysis showed a mean residual discrepancy of 2.81 ± 1.99 mm relative to pre-harvesting morphology. All patients were discharged within 24 hours in stable condition, reporting minimal postoperative discomfort and no postoperative complications. Conclusion: The proposed AI-powered 3D imaging workflow is reliable and clinically applicable for assessing ABG outcomes and mandibular symphysis donor site bone regeneration. In this cohort, L-PRF does not significantly influence volumetric bone formation, regardless of graft source, and no interaction between graft type and L-PRF was observed. Bone regeneration at the mandibular symphysis donor site was high, with no permanent complications.
PURPOSE
To identify independent preoperative three-dimensional (3D) morphological predictors for postoperative bone bridge formation in secondary alveolar bone grafting (SABG) using cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT), and to propose an optimal surgical strategy based on these quantitative indicators.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
This study evaluated 100 patients who underwent SABG. Preoperative and 6-month postoperative CBCT images were analysed. Patients were categorized into three surgical stages: lateral incisor eruption (Stage 1), canine eruption (Stage 2), and the multi-bracket treatment period (Stage 3). Preoperative cleft dimensions (volume, area and width) and postoperative outcomes (bone bridge thickness, height, and residual defect volume) were measured. Multiple linear regression analysis was performed to identify independent preoperative predictors of surgical success.
RESULTS
Multivariate analysis revealed that a larger preoperative cleft volume strongly predicted decreased postoperative bone bridge thickness at the mesial aspect (p < 0.001). Furthermore, a larger preoperative cleft area at the root apex was a significant independent predictor of decreased mesial bone bridge thickness (p = 0.019), and a wider preoperative cleft at the midportion strongly predicted decreased bone bridge height (p = 0.001). Volumetric analysis showed that patients in Stage 3 exhibited significantly larger preoperative cleft volumes. Consequently, while the absolute dimensions of the newly formed bone bridges did not differ significantly among the stages, Stage 3 patients were left with significantly larger postoperative residual bone defects.
CONCLUSION
The preoperative cleft volume, apical cleft area, and middle cleft width evaluated via CBCT are robust independent predictors of SABG outcomes. To minimize postoperative residual dead space and optimise bone filling, surgical intervention is strongly recommended during Stage 1 or 2, prior to the severe morphological expansion of the alveolar cleft.
Toshiro Kibe, Yuhei Kamikuri, M. Tezuka et al.· Orthodontics & craniofacial...· 0 citations
Within the limitations of this study, intentionally exposing the xenogeneic collagen matrix seal yielded comparable outcomes in non-contained and contained sockets, which may reflect the material's ability to reduce the adverse effects of socket-wall resorption.
Xinyi Zhou, Yuping Hong, Yang Yang et al.· Journal of Periodontal & Imp...· 0 citations
Objective
To evaluate the clinical and radiographic outcomes of membrane-free guided tissue regeneration (GTR) using enamel matrix derivative (EMD) with bone grafts in dogs with vertical infrabony periodontal defects.
Methods
This retrospective study reviewed cases of client-owned dogs that underwent membrane-free GTR using EMD in combination with bone grafts between August 1, 2023, and September 30, 2025. Outcomes were assessed from records and cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) datasets using 2-D measurements of clinical attachment loss (CAL) and vertical bone defect ratio (VBDR) and 3-D volumetric analysis. Success was defined as CAL improvement (≥ 1 mm) and VBDR reduction (> 10%). Volumetric analysis was used to quantify infrabony defect fill.
Results
20 periodontal defects in 16 dogs were included (allograft, n = 10; xenograft, 10). Median follow-up was 7 months (range, 6 to 14 months). All defects met the success criteria. Median CAL decreased from 5.0 mm (range, 3.0 to 8.0 mm) to 2.0 mm (range, 1.0 to 3.0 mm), and median VBDR decreased from 0.42 (range, 0.16 to 0.78) to 0.18 (range, 0.04 to 0.46). Volumetric analysis revealed a median infrabony defect fill of 98.49% (range, 71.86% to 100.00%).
Conclusions
Membrane-free GTR with EMD was associated with clinically meaningful periodontal improvement and substantial infrabony defect fill in appropriately selected canine patients with vertical infrabony defects. Prospective, controlled studies are warranted to further evaluate its efficacy and indications.
Clinical Relevance
This membrane-free regenerative approach may provide a practical tooth-preserving treatment option for selected small-breed dogs when conventional barrier-membrane placement is technically challenging.
Daehyun Kwon, Y. Jang, Gyumin Kim· American Journal of Veterina...· 0 citations