Skip to content
Book Open access

Visualizing Placement Proposals for Window Arrangement in Mixed Reality: A Comparative User Study

Aug 2026 · Proceedings of the 2026 ACM Symposium on Spatial User Interaction · 0 citations · 62 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

This work compares three proposal-visualization techniques for window placement, Situated Icon Preview, Situated Window Preview, and 3D Preview, against a Manual Positioning baseline and discusses the factors shaping this preference, as well as outline implications for hybrid approaches.

Abstract

Adaptive mixed reality (MR) interfaces typically optimize window layouts on behalf of the user, with limited consideration for individual preferences. A promising alternative keeps users in the loop by presenting layout proposals for them to select from, but how these proposals should be visualized remains underexplored. We compare three proposal-visualization techniques for window placement, Situated Icon Preview, Situated Window Preview, and 3D Preview, against a Manual Positioning baseline. The techniques differ in level of detail and degree of interaction-space context. In a within-subjects user study, 24 participants completed a multi-stage trip-planning task in VR, individually placing seven sequentially introduced windows using each technique. We thereby focus on single-window placement under predefined proposal positions. We measured layouting time, number of layout changes, task load, user experience, and preference, complemented by semi-structured interviews. Although Situated Icon Preview and Situated Window Preview reduced layouting time compared to Manual Positioning — with Situated Window Preview also faster than 3D Preview — participants preferred direct manual control. We discuss the factors shaping this preference (perceived control, cognitive cost, familiarity, and informativeness of the proposal) and outline implications for hybrid approaches, as a promising combination of proposal-based suggestions with manual refinement.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Aug 2026

Implications of user-controlled architectural design on spatial experience in virtual reality workspaces

This study aims to explore how spatial design personalization influences users’ emotional, cognitive and functional experiences in immersive virtual reality workspaces (VRWSs), addressing the lack of understanding about how user-driven spatial design in VRWSs shapes workspace satisfaction and perceived productivity...

Kyunghyun Cho, Seung Hyun Lee, S. Cha · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Optimizing Immersive Exhibition Space Design Using Adaptive Simulated Annealing with Reheating and Virtual Reality Evaluation.

Immersive exhibition spaces require layouts that support efficient circulation, clear wayfinding, balanced interaction, and comfortable environmental experience. However, exhibition layouts are often developed through manual design decisions, which makes it difficult to simultaneously evaluate route length, visual acce...

Guang-Ping Zhang, Xiang-Hui Hui, Han-Ye Wang · 0 citations
Book Open access Oct 2026

Embracing Spheres and Portals: Comparing Multi-Choice Transition Techniques for Extended Reality Environments

Transitions are important for switching between different environments or scenes, but many contemporary Extended Reality (XR) applications employ transition techniques adapted from traditional flat-screen media, leaving a gap for solutions that leverage XR’s immersive three-dimensional capabilities. Additionally, prior...

M. Friedrich, Lucie Wittig, Frank Steinicke · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Behavior Setting Map: guiding content design for real-world VR applications

Virtual Reality (VR) applications based on real-world contexts, such as training, healthcare, and entertainment, rely on varying degrees of replication of real settings. However, there is a lack of systematic design support for determining which elements of a setting to retain or modify. We propose Behavior Setting M...

Xiao-Yang Zhao, S. Deterding, R. Aunger et al. · 0 citations

Beyond Task Performance: Lessons Learned from Evaluating an Exploratory VR Interaction Technique

A within-subjects user study comparing RodCast with Go-Go Hand and FlowerCone across three representative interaction tasks revealed that the proposed implementation incurred performance costs on more demanding manipulation tasks, while qualitative feedback suggested that participants attributed these challenges to the...

Nevzat Umut Demirseren, Corey R. Pittman, I. B. Adhanom et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.