Skip to content
Open access

Systematic benchmarking and optimal strategy selection of cross-species integration methods

Sep 2026 · Briefings in Bioinformatics · Vol 27 · 0 citations · 68 references
Medicine

TL;DR

The findings show that selecting highly variable one-to-one orthologous genes best balances species differences and commonalities, and scVI, a probabilistic model with distributions specified by deep neural networks, and its semi-supervised extension scANVI, effectively mapped distantly related species.

Abstract

Abstract Single-cell RNA sequencing provides an unprecedented resolution for cellular heterogeneity and gene regulation, fostering cross-species comparative analyses with increasing interspecies data. However, integrating single-cell transcriptomic data faces challenges, including gene selection, evolutionary distance, and batch effects, with varying method performances. We utilized single-cell transcriptomic data from hippocampal tissues of seven mammals (e.g. mouse, human), evaluating 13 mainstream integration methods across 27 tasks with 11 metrics. To compare the performance of different methods, we developed a machine learning-based scoring model that assesses the contribution of each metric in a data-driven manner, thereby addressing the oversimplified assumptions of traditional manual weighting approaches. Our findings show that selecting highly variable one-to-one orthologous genes best balances species differences and commonalities. Most methods integrated closely related species, whereas scVI, a probabilistic model with distributions specified by deep neural networks, and its semi‑supervised extension scANVI, as well as the Seurat v5 method, which uses reciprocal principal component analysis (RPCAv5), effectively mapped distantly related species. Increased species numbers reduce gene overlap and heighten heterogeneity, increasing integration difficulty. The scANVI best maintained quality by balancing the biological signals and batch effect removal. Furthermore, we established an evaluation website to guide researchers in selecting the optimal integration methods for cross-species single-cell transcriptomic data analysis. Collectively, our findings provide a systematic, evidence-based framework that can assist researchers in rapidly selecting appropriate integration methods for cross-species single-cell transcriptomic studies.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Nov 2026

SigBridgeR: An R Toolkit for Standardized Identification and Benchmarking of Phenotype-Associated Cell Subpopulations in Single-Cell Transcriptomics.

BACKGROUND Single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) has revolutionized our understanding of cellular heterogeneity, yet linking specific cell subpopulations to clinically relevant phenotypes remains a major challenge. Although multiple computational methods have been developed to integrate bulk transcriptomic and single-...

Yu-Xi Yang, Hong-Qian Qian, Ze-Yu Yan et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access 2026

A Systematic Literature Review of Single-Cell Foundation Models for Transcriptomics: Design, Adaptation, Benchmarks, and Future Directions

Large single-cell atlases have enabled reusable representation learning across tissues, diseases, platforms, and species. Single-cell foundation models (scFMs) build on these resources by learning cell- and gene-level representations from large-scale transcriptomic data. However, current scFMs vary substantially in inp...

Xin Zhao, Yee-Yong Pang, Tong-Ye Fu et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Regularized logistic regression-based gene selection for functional analysis of heterogeneous scRNA-seq macrophage populations in muscle aging and regeneration

Background Single-cell RNA sequencing enables the characterization of heterogeneous cellular responses across experimental conditions. However, feature-selection methods often prioritize genes associated with global condition differences while overlooking subgroup-specific transcriptional structure. This limitation is...

Tiago M. Costa, Marta B. Lopes, Joana Neves et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

scGEN: Leveraging an Adaptive Weighting Strategy for Challenging Cell Clustering in Single‐Cell RNA‐seq

ABSTRACT Recent advancements in single‐cell RNA sequencing (scRNA‐seq) have greatly enhanced our ability to dissect cellular heterogeneity. However, unsupervised clustering often struggles to identify transitional or developmental boundary cells, as existing methods rely on highly variable genes without considering exp...

Fang Huang, Da-Yu Hu, Ya-Qi Dai et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

BEAR-GRN: Systematic assessment of single-cell multi-omics-based gene regulatory network inference methods

Identifying regulatory gene interactions is inherently challenging as it depends on both the transcriptional and epigenetic landscapes. Multiple methods are proposed to infer gene regulatory networks (GRNs) using single-cell multi-omics data, yet the absence of a standardized benchmarking framework remains an obstacle...

Karamveer Karamveer, Eric Moeller, Hannah Valensi et al. · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

SCAN: a cross-species single-cell transcriptome resource for domestic animals—revealing divergent spermatogenesis in avian and mammalian systems

Despite the astonishing growth of livestock single-cell transcriptome data, its full potential is severely limited by the lack of specialized functional databases and annotation tools. The ability to systematically integrate, standardize, and deeply interpret livestock single-cell data remains very limited. This study...

Yuan-Fang Li, Qian-Ran Wei, Guo-Xi Li et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.