Skip to content
Review

From silicon to synapse: Why the artificial unit is not a kind of neuron.

Sep 2026 · Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews · Vol 191, pp. 106944 · 0 citations · 71 references
Medicine

TL;DR

The term "artificial neuron" is a historical metaphor that has outlived its usefulness as a scientific description and the conflation of artificial units with biological neurons is a source of persistent confusion in both AI research and public understanding.

Abstract

The computational units of large language models (LLMs)-artificial neurons, attention heads, and weight matrices-differ from biological neurons not merely in degree but in kind. This paper develops that empirical argument across three levels of biological organization: the single neuron, the local circuit, and whole-brain dynamics. At the single-neuron level, biological neurons are self-maintaining electrochemical processes sustained by continuous ATP-dependent ion pumping, activity-dependent morphological remodeling, and spike-timing-dependent plasticity (STDP) grounded in local calcium dynamics at individual synapses; artificial units are stateless, memoryless scalar transformations with no metabolic basis. At the circuit level, cortical columns implement laminar excitatory-inhibitory balance and self-organized collective oscillatory dynamics that are absent from the feedforward, batch-normalized layer stacks of transformer architectures. At the systems level, the brain sustains always-on intrinsic dynamics, homeostatic regulation, and circadian entrainment; LLMs are stateless between inferences and possess no equivalent of resting-state activity. Across all three levels, the differences are organizational rather than scalar: they concern the mode of existence of the processing units, not merely the quantity or speed of processing. We conclude that the term "artificial neuron" is a historical metaphor that has outlived its usefulness as a scientific description, and that the conflation of artificial units with biological neurons is a source of persistent confusion in both AI research and public understanding. Replacing the metaphor with precise empirical description is a precondition for accurate evaluation of what LLMs can and cannot do.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Design and Verification of Adaptive LIF Neurons: From Single-Neuron Dynamics to Multi-Neuron Spiking Networks

This work contributes a 2nd-order adaptive LIF neuron with two-stage synaptic filtering for richer temporal dynamics; a fully connected six-neuron spiking network with configurable weights demonstrating weight-based inter-neuron communication; and a direct verification methodology enabling per-cycle observation of all...

T. Pham, Riadul Islam · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Sep 2026

DVA-Neurons: Design and Verification of Adaptive LIF Neurons: From Single-Neuron Dynamics to Multi-Neuron Spiking Networks

A 2nd-order neuron with two-stage synaptic filtering for richer temporal dynamics; a fully-connected 6-neuron spiking network with configurable weights demonstrating weight-based inter-neuron communication; and a direct verification methodology enabling per-cycle observation of all internal states are contributed.

T. Pham, Riadul Islam · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Spatio-temporal plasticity in coupled stochastic relaxation-type oscillators

The functioning of the human brain is still not completely understood but key features such as brain oscillations on a macroscopic level and stochastic spiking together with structural plasticity on a microscopic level stand out. As its energy efficiency in cognitive tasks, e. g. pattern recognition, is still unmatch...

Maximiliane Mewis-Noll, Roshani Madurawala, Tom Birkoben et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Oct 2026

The Dormant Spiking Neuron: A State-Driven Mechanism for Efficient Spiking Neural Networks

Spiking neural networks (SNNs) offer a compelling pathway toward energy-efficient artificial intelligence, fundamentally anchored in presynaptic input-driven sparsity. However, a substantial yet chronically overlooked source of computational overhead persists: the continuous subthreshold dynamics of postsynaptic neuron...

Ruichen Ma, Yi-Cai Chen, Pu-Jun Zhou et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Sep 2026

A Spiking Neural Network Model of Elementary Self-Consciousness via Endogenous Default Mode Network Dynamics

Understanding the neurobiological mechanisms underlying self-referential cognition and baseline self-consciousness remains a fundamental challenge in computational neuroscience. In this work, we propose a large-scale computational model incorporating a 10,000-neuron spiking neural network (SNN) based on Izhikevich dyna...

R. Lahoz-Beltra · 0 citations
Preprint Oct 2026

Excitability across scales: a unifying EI model

Neuronal excitability is commonly modeled using different principles at the cellular and population scales, making it difficult to study how microscopic mechanisms shape macroscopic activity. We introduce a spatiotemporal excitatory-inhibitory (EI) model that unifies these scales through a common mixed-feedback archite...

Thomas S. J. Burger, R. Sepulchre · 2 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.