Can evolution be predicted and how does this affect Big History
Gerard Jagers Op Akkerhuis G.A.J.M
Jul 2026· Journal of Big History· Vol 9, pp. 181-195· 0 citations· 44 references
TL;DR
A new perspective on complexity increase based on a stepwise process termed dual closure, which suggests that the emergence of technical beings is a likely next step in physical and biological evolution.
Abstract
Can our understanding of evolution be used to make predictions, both within biology and on larger historical scales? Opinions diverge. Skeptics emphasize that contingency and chance—such as random genetic variation and drift— preclude detailed prediction. In contrast, proponents point to recurring patterns and general trends, such as the evolution of consumers in the presence of food, and the long-term increase in organismal complexity and information processing from bacteria to multicellular life. This article introduces a new perspective on complexity increase based on a stepwise process termed dual closure. Dual closure refers to the couplings, one after the other, of the combinations of a cyclic process with its containment. For example, the transition from molecular to bacterial systems involved the closure of catalytic reaction networks, coupled with their encapsulation by a membrane. The result is a hierarchy linking physical and biological evolution. Extrapolating from this hierarchy suggests that the emergence of technical beings is a likely next step.
Gene copy-number mutations are frequent and prevalent yet often overlooked. While initially considered to be the neutrally evolving raw material needed for the emergence of new genes through the process of gene duplication and divergence, recent technical advances and renewed interest start to unravel a fundamentally d...
Environmental change is ubiquitous in nature, yet understanding its effect on the predictability of evolution remains a challenge. Previous work in microbes has shown that growth and fitness in a particular environment can depend strongly on the environments encountered previously. If such history-dependent effects are...
Shaili Mathur, Clare I. Abreu, Olivia M. Ghosh et al.· bioRxiv· 0 citations
We study the evolution of sexually reproducing populations subjected to sudden environmental changes. Using an individual based model we consider scenarios where abrupt changes can affect the carrying capacity, the mating range or the strength of assortativity, that controls the minimum similarity between individuals t...
It is argued that current explanatory practice misses two situations that can arise in any lineage, not only the authors': dynamic: traits continue changing in one direction when a lineage's own niche construction keeps enlarging the problem it faces.
M. Ben-Dor, Ran Barkai· Evolutionary Anthropology (p...· 0 citations
The repeated evolution of similar phenotypes in response to shared ecological pressures provides striking examples of natural selection and raises broader questions about the predictability of evolution. Evolutionary constraint may shape this predictability, while the apparent extent of parallelism may also depend on t...
Zachary J. C. Tobias, D. Rennison· bioRxiv· 0 citations