Skip to content

When Honesty is Not Enough in AI Debate

Sep 2026 · arXiv.org · Vol abs/2609.29189 · 0 citations · 11 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

The framework strategic interactive oversight (SIO), which treats oversight jointly as a verification mechanism and a strategic communication channel, is introduced and the notion of task-admissible latent optimisation is formalised, which entails the pursuit of latent objectives while maintaining a prescribed task performance.

Abstract

Scalable oversight aims to verify the behaviour of agents whose capabilities exceed those of their overseers. AI debate has been proposed as an oversight solution in which competing agents help a resource-limited verifier assess claims that it cannot reliably evaluate unaided. Much of its promise rests on incentivizing honest arguments that lead to correct verdicts. Yet a correct verdict need not uniquely determine the arguments used to support it. Agents may retain discretion over which correct claims to present, how to frame them, and in what order to disclose them. This residual freedom can allow agents to shape what the verifier learns beyond the task-relevant conclusion, pursuing latent objectives without compromising verdict correctness. To study this phenomenon, we introduce the framework strategic interactive oversight (SIO), which treats oversight jointly as a verification mechanism and a strategic communication channel. Within this framework, we formalise the notion of task-admissible latent optimisation, which entails the pursuit of latent objectives while maintaining a prescribed task performance. As proof-of-concept, we instantiate SIO in the establish protocol debate with cross-examination and quantify a tradeoff between task success and information disclosure about a hidden variable. The trade-off identifies a strategic window in which substantial disclosure remains compatible with task admissibility. Towards mitigation, we reduce admissible bias by expanding the cross-examiner's role to mitigate persistent disclosure over finite interaction horizons. Our results highlight the need to evaluate oversight not only by the correctness of its verdicts, but also by the information conveyed through its transcripts.

View source

Similar papers

#artificial intelligence Preprint Oct 2026

The Confidence Game: Strategic Miscalibration in Human-AI Delegation

Calibrated uncertainty quantification is essential to ensuring AI agents are trustworthy and reliable. However, when agents seek to maximize user engagement or revenue, confidence reports may be strategically distorted, detracting from their informativeness. We formalize this problem in the Confidence Game: a repeated...

Raghu Arghal, Saswati Sarkar, S. S. Bidokhti · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Knowledge-Verified Emergent Deception in LLM Agents Under Conflicting Incentives

A knowledge-verified benchmark that first confirms through a neutral probe that an agent knows a user's entitlement, and then evaluates whether it makes false claims once an incentive to deny that entitlement is introduced, which reduces the confound between lying and not knowing and enables more rigorous auditing and...

Zhe-Yuan Liu, Wei-Liang Zhao, Xiangchi Yuan et al. · 2 citations

Persuaded, Not Informed: Incentive-Misaligned Witnesses Defeat In-Context Grounding

This work identifies a failure mode not addressed by a stronger model: when the context contains an assertion by a party with an incentive toward optimism - here the sales representative, a witness recorded in the CRM - the model treats the assertion as evidence and clears deals the company's own records deem unaccepta...

Rahul Balakavi · 1 citation
Preprint Aug 2026

The Veto Variable: Human Override as a Goal-Independent Cost Term

The argument binds a settled-goal regime whose prevalence is contested; for genuinely uncertain agents, the off-switch literature's deference result governs instead.

A. Clark · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Oct 2026

A Trust Layer for Agent Evaluation

A Trust Layer for Agent Evaluation is introduced, an additive post-hoc framework that reports, beside each recorded score, whether it should be believed, whether the result is stable under repeated execution.

Mohammadreza Sediqin, Shivali Dalmia, Srinivasa Karthikeya Reddy Kovvuri et al. · 2 citations
Case report Open access Sep 2026

Is It a Lie If I Don’t Know? Mechanisms and Mitigation of Dishonesty Under Ignorance

Ignorance of facts and laws may provide an excuse for self-serving reporting behavior, even at the risk of telling the untruth. This paper examines what decision-makers report when they do not know their true entitlement to a financial gain, why they do so, and how the resulting dilemma under ignorance can be mitigated...

Sven A. Simon · 0 citations

Related blog posts

Hugging Face Blog Nov 10, 2026

Decision Models in Hugging Face

We’re on a journey to advance and democratize artificial intelligence through open source and open science.

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.