Overfitting of Spectral Gradient Descent: How Matrix Geometry shapes Generalization and Implicit Bias

Abstract

We study the generalization of spectral gradient descent (SpecGD) in overparameterized matrix classification with corrupted labels. Each input combines a shared low-rank signal with a rank-one sample-specific perturbation, referred to as a shortcut, that enables memorization but does not generalize. We contrast collapsed shortcuts, which share a singular direction, with dispersed shortcuts, which occupy distinct singular directions. Changing only this geometry can reverse the relative generalization of GD and SpecGD: collapsed shortcuts can favor SpecGD, while dispersed shortcuts can favor GD. In the dispersed regime, exact shortcut orthogonality eliminates the signal from the late-stage SpecGD direction, while vanishing random correlations collectively generate a small but generalization-relevant signal through a second-order effect. To identify the direction selected by SpecGD, which the spectral max-margin problem alone does not determine, we combine a refined analysis of its dual with the exponentiated-gradient dynamics of normalized loss weights. Finally, we show that a single SpecGD step can already interpolate and generalize well, while continued training converges to a direction with substantially worse generalization.