Skip to content
Open access

Democracy for Whom? Herrenvolk Democracy and the American Founding

Aug 2026 · PS · 0 citations · 4 references

Abstract

As the United States marks the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence amid democratic erosion, this article asks why 250 years of democratic development have not produced a multiracial democracy. It argues that the United States is a herrenvolk democracy—a regime in which democracy coexists with racialized limits on political membership and governing power. By examining colonial law, the Declaration, the Constitution, and the Naturalization Act of 1790, I show how the founding joined popular sovereignty to racial exclusion in ways that continue to shape struggles over belonging, representation, and coercive power. The legacy of 1776 includes both the Declaration’s democratic promise and a durable model for how democracy can coexist with exclusion.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access 2026

Reimagining Democratic Institutions for a New American Century

Equality of voice and representation is a foundational value of American democracy anda prerequisite for democratic renewal and adaptation in the twenty-first century. This essay considers the potential and progress made toward three structural reforms – expanding the House of Representatives, implementing Supreme Cour...

Wallace B. Jefferson · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Can Nationalism Be Democratic?

Nationalism and democracy are often presented as natural allies: National self‐determination is best achieved through democratic institutions, while a shared national identity generates the trust and willingness to compromise that stable democracies need. This article, however, explores two possible points of confl...

David Miller · 0 citations
Book 2015

Virtue and Irony in American Democracy

What virtues are necessary for democracy to succeed? This book turns to John Dewey and Reinhold Niebuhr, two of America’s most influential theorists of democracy, to answer this question. Dewey and Niebuhr both implied—although for very different reasons—that humility and mutuality are important virtues for the success...

Daniel A. Morris · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Collective Self-Rule and Comprehensive Participation: A Critique of Council Democracy

This article critically explores council democracy as a utopian state order, on the basis of anarchist and Marxist works from western Europe and the United States, post-World War 2. As a system of national government, council democracy cannot possibly deliver on its utopian promises. Collective self-rule cannot put an...

E. van Ree · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Democracy against Equality

This book traces the shifting contours of caste and agrarian inequality, revealing how older hierarchies are being reconfigured in new forms and how they impact democracy. It offers a compelling ethnographic account of how democratic mechanisms-including political participation, elections, and protest movements-actuall...

N. Martín · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Michail Theodosiadis:

If political tyranny implies the exclusion of the people from public affairs, then freedom is the practice of common ownership of political institutions. Theodosiadis (2025:5-6) develops this approach by tracing its ancient Greek roots, clarifying its American traditions and identifying its institutional forms for a de...

Eleni Boliaki · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.