Skip to content
Review Open access

Defining, Operationalizing, and Measuring Generative AI Competence among Vocational Teachers: A Scoping Review

Sep 2026 · International Journal of Educational Practice and Policy · Vol 4, pp. 37-55 · 0 citations · 24 references

TL;DR

This review charted how generative AI competence among vocational teachers has been defined, operationalized, and measured in the Scopus Q1 indexed literature published between 2021 and 2026 and suggested that generative AI competence for vocational teachers remains comparatively under-theorized and under measured next to its counterpart in general education.

Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) tools such as ChatGPT have spread quickly enough that teachers are now widely expected to develop competence in applying these technologies to instruction. Technical and vocational education and training (TVET) faces this pressure with particular force, since its teachers must simultaneously satisfy pedagogical demands, keep pace with rapidly changing technology, and stay aligned with industry practice. Research on "generative AI competence," however, has not kept these demands in a coherent frame: overlapping labels among them AI literacy, AI self-efficacy, and AI TPACK are applied inconsistently across studies, leaving the construct conceptually fragmented. Using an established scoping-review framework and reporting the process per PRISMA ScR guidance, this review charted how generative AI competence among vocational teachers has been defined, operationalized, and measured in the Scopus Q1 indexed literature published between 2021 and 2026. A structured search of five databases plus citation tracking sources identified 222 records, 28 of which all Scopus Q1 indexed satisfied the eligibility criteria after screening. Definitions in this set span a wide range, from narrowly tool specific notions such as prompt engineering competence to broad, multidimensional constructs embedded in knowledge based frameworks such as Intelligent TPACK. Operationalization efforts cluster around adaptations of three frameworks the UNESCO AI Competency Framework for Teachers, DigCompEdu, and various TPACK derived models while measurement has relied almost exclusively on self report Likert instruments; only a single instrument has been validated specifically on a vocational-teacher sample. Taken together, these patterns indicate that generative AI competence for vocational teachers remains comparatively under-theorized and under measured next to its counterpart in general education. To help close that gap, the review proposes a three layer integrative model encompassing foundational AI literacy, pedagogical technical integration, and an industry aligned contextual layer intended to guide future instrument development and the design of professional training.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Sep 2026

Teachers and Generative AI: A Systematic Review of Adoption, Competence, Professional Development, and Socio-Technical Experiences

It is argued that effective integration requires aligning technological, human, and organizational systems and outlines an agenda for context-sensitive, practice-oriented research.

Sara Ayubian, Génesis Aguilar Chávez, Ernestina Wiafe et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

AI and Constructivist Pedagogy in TVET: A Scoping Review of Integration Mechanisms, Competencies, and Implementation Challenges

Findings indicate that problem-based learning and project-based learning are the dominant constructivist approaches, supported by generative AI and intelligent tutoring systems in TVET contexts.

Yi-Lin Jiang, M. Omar, Fathiyah Kamaruzaman · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Open access Oct 2026

Empirically Grounding and Refining a Model for Teachers’ AI-Related Competences: Insights from Expert Interviews

This study examines and refines an existing competence model by incorporating perspectives from diverse stakeholder groups and elaborated to provide an empirically grounded, didactically actionable framework for teacher education and future research.

Luca Mikula · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Architects or assistants? A grounded theory of how vocational managers and technical students renegotiate academic integrity in the era of generative AI

A substantive theory explaining how academic integrity is renegotiated within competency-based technical and vocational education and training (TVET) is developed and a process theory explaining how educational institutions sustain legitimacy, human agency, and professional judgment within increasingly distributed huma...

A. Jadjuli, Rosema Lukman, Kaizer J. Asibih et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

From digital competence to AI-responsive pedagogy: a scoping review of technology-supported teacher education

Across both evidence streams, technological affordances became educationally meaningful when mediated by pedagogical design, disciplinary knowledge, critical and ethical judgement, human oversight, professional agency, and institutional support.

John Fredy Patiño Hernández, Andrés Chiappe, Eric Ortega González · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Advancing Engineering-Driven STEM Pedagogy with AI

This record-level systematic synthesis examines 50 Scopus-indexed records at the intersection of engineering education, higher education, and teacher AI literacy, with attention to AI integration and human– AI collaboration, suggesting that AI is most defensible when it augments human agency within EDP -aligned work...

Jing-Yu Lu, Xiao-Fei Zhou · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.