Meditation and breathwork on anxiety in Parkinson's disease: A pilot randomized controlled trial
TL;DR
Remotely-delivered meditation and breathwork through the BSM program significantly reduced anxiety in individuals with Parkinson's Disease in the authors' study and may be a promising non-pharmacological therapy.
Abstract
Background Anxiety and other non-motor symptoms can greatly diminish quality of life in people with Parkinson's Disease (PD). Yet, few randomized controlled trials (RCTs) have assessed accessible, non-pharmacological mental health treatments for people with PD. Objective To assess the feasibility and impact of brief, remotely-delivered meditation and breathwork on neuropsychiatric symptoms in people with PD. Methods In this 18-week RCT, intervention participants attended weekly webinars for six weeks, while waitlisted controls maintained their usual routine before crossing over at six weeks. Participants were assessed for weekly compliance trends (primary outcome) and changes in anxiety (primary outcome), depression, perceived stress, and other non-motor symptoms at 6-week intervals: baseline and weeks 6 (T2), 12 (T3), and 18 (T4). Weekly compliance was collected in each group for 12 weeks. Anxiety was measured using the Parkinson's Anxiety Scale. Results There was a significant decrease in the primary outcome, anxiety, in the intervention group (n = 17) compared to the waitlist control (n = 21) after 6 weeks of meditation and breathwork practice (mean difference (MD)= −5.0, 95% CI [−9.5, −0.49], P = .03). Within-group analysis further confirmed a significant reduction in anxiety (MD = −4.7, 95% CI [2.10,7.33], P < .001) in the intervention group (n = 28). Thirty-one percent of participants met the compliance definition. Conclusion Remotely-delivered meditation and breathwork through the BSM program significantly reduced anxiety in individuals with PD in our study and may be a promising non-pharmacological therapy. A larger RCT with continuous wellness coaching is warranted to more rigorously assess efficacy and optimize protocols. Clinical trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT05335850, https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05335850 Plain language summary Study on whether meditation and breathwork practices improves anxiety in people with Parkinson's Disease and if it is possible to keep up with these practices Why was the study done? Mental health is greatly affected in those with Parkinson's Disease, reducing quality of life. Accessible treatments specifically for anxiety and other non-motor symptoms other than medications are not well studied. Since previous studies have shown their potential to reduce anxiety safely and at no cost, the research team examined online (virtual) meditation and breathwork for individuals with Parkinsons. What did the researchers do? The research team randomly placed 48 participants in one of two groups (24 participants each) for this 18-week study. The first group learned the meditation and breathwork practices through the Breath, Sound, and Meditation program in the first 6 weeks of the study through guided webinars, while the comparison waited 6 weeks before learning the practices. Participants were asked to answer weekly questions about their practice frequency for 12 weeks. Surveys measured anxiety, depression, stress, and other non-motor symptoms at the beginning of the study, 6, 12, and 18 weeks. What did the researchers find? The research team reported that anxiety levels dropped in the group that learned the meditation and breathwork practices compared to the group that did not learn in the first 6 weeks. The anxiety levels also remained lower 12-weeks after the participants learned the practices compared to baseline. There were no changes in depression, stress, or other non-motor symptoms. Thirty-one percent of participants completed the practices regularly. What do the findings mean? The meditation and breathwork practices decreased anxiety levels in individuals with Parkinson's Disease. The practices could be a promising tool to improve Parkinson's-associated mental health symptoms. However, since this study was done with a small number of participants, a larger research study is needed to understand the full impact of the meditation and breathwork practices.