A systematic architecture-aware evaluation protocol is presented to assess the effectiveness of nine widely used XAI techniques across four categories of DL models: very deep, lightweight, transformer-based and hybrid neural networks.
Abstract
Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) has become essential in medical image analysis to ensure transparency of deep learning (DL)-based diagnostic systems. However, selecting appropriate XAI techniques for breast cancer recognition remains largely ad hoc, with limited systematic evaluation across different DL architectures. This study presents a systematic architecture-aware evaluation protocol to assess the effectiveness of nine widely used XAI techniques across four categories of DL models: very deep, lightweight, transformer-based and hybrid neural networks. The evaluation is conducted on a breast ultrasound dataset comprising 780 images using clinically aligned spatial metrics, including Pointing Game, Intersection over Union and Mean Coverage, to quantify agreement between generated explanations and expert-annotated lesion regions. Results indicate that explanation quality is primarily influenced by the interaction between model architecture and XAI method, rather than any single technique consistently outperforming others. Hybrid architectures produce more spatially coherent explanations, while lightweight and transformer-based models exhibit greater variability across methods. The findings show that no single technique generalises across architectures and evaluation criteria, emphasising the need for joint selection of DL models and XAI techniques. Explainability depends on both model design and explanation strategy and should not be considered independently. This work provides a structured evaluation protocol and practical guidance for selecting XAI techniques in breast cancer diagnosis, supporting more transparent clinical decision-support systems. \textcolor{blue}{Code is publicly available at https://github.com/Nishan-Charlie/Explainable-AI}
These findings suggest that interpretability quality can be quantitatively assessed and improved through multi-method and ensemble-based analysis and enhances explanation robustness and supports reliable and transparent clinical decision support for prostate magnetic resonance imaging.
M. Gulum, M. Kantardzic, Christopher M. Trombley et al.· Computer Methods and Program...· 0 citations
Breast cancer diagnosis from histopathological images remains a critical yet challenging task due to high intra-class variability and reliance on expert interpretation. Although deep learning models have achieved promising results, many existing approaches suffer from limited interpretability and insufficient modelling...
B. Kaur, R. Popli, R. Ghoniem et al.· Revista Internacional de Mét...· 0 citations
A comprehensive deep learning-based framework that leverages three benchmark datasets—PH2, ISIC (Benign vs Malignant), and HAM10000—using transfer learning and ensemble techniques is presented, demonstrating a notable increase in classification accuracy.
A. D. Hayder, J. Saeed· passer of basic and applied...· 0 citations
Background: Deep learning approaches, especially convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and Vision Transformers (ViTs), have made substantial progress in breast cancer classification from histopathological images. Yet, previous CNN–ViT-based architectures frequently demonstrate insufficient generalization when evaluated...
An Explainable Hybrid Machine Learning (XML) framework that integrates advanced feature extraction with interpretable classification techniques for early breast cancer detection and staging and offers a robust, transparent, and clinically auditable solution for personalized breast cancer diagnosis and treatment plannin...
Shubhangi, Sanjeev Sharma, Akhtar Husain· International journal of com...· 0 citations
Globally, breast cancer-related mortality among women requires early and precise diagnostic support to improve patient outcomes. The existing research work discusses using Machine learning and deep learning models for precise diagnosis with a combination of classified outcomes using various datasets. The proposed work...
Arthi Rengaraj, Manoj Kumar Devendran, Mahesh Kumar Nadesan et al.· Artificial Intelligence in H...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.