Jul 2026· Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy· Vol 33 4, pp.
e70320
· 0 citations· 28 references
Medicine
TL;DR
Five key predictors of dropout emerged: younger age, unemployment, a higher number of comorbid Axis I disorders, absence of a partner, and moderate depression severity, and all models showed reduced performance during external validation.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION
Dropout from psychotherapy for major depressive disorder (MDD) undermines treatment effectiveness for both patients and clinicians. Early identification of individuals at risk of discontinuation is therefore essential. Machine learning methods, particularly those incorporating resampling techniques to address imbalanced clinical data, may offer improved predictive capacity. This study evaluates several machine-learning approaches to determine their potential in identifying patients at elevated risk of dropout.
Methods
Data were drawn from a randomised controlled trial of outpatients with MDD (n = 290) receiving short-term psychodynamic supportive psychotherapy (SPSP) or cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). Candidate predictors were restricted to variables available in both the development and external validation datasets, resulting in a limited number of overlapping predictors. Multiple machine learning models and resampling strategies were applied to predict dropout, and the best-performing models were subsequently externally validated using an independent clinical dataset (n = 96).
Results
Models demonstrated low predictive performance overall. Resampling strategies influenced outcomes, with SMOTE consistently improving F1-scores compared with no resampling. The combination of random forest with SMOTE achieved the highest F1-score (0.303). Five key predictors of dropout emerged: younger age, unemployment, a higher number of comorbid Axis I disorders, absence of a partner, and moderate depression severity. All models showed reduced performance during external validation.
Discussion
The models showed very limited predictive performance, which may in part reflect the restricted predictor set resulting from the requirement that variables be assessed in both trials. While clinical application is premature at this stage, the findings provide a valuable proof of concept and highlight key methodological challenges inherent in cross-trial dropout prediction. Despite this, the identified predictors are routinely available in clinical practice, suggesting that future models, if developed with richer predictor sets and validated in larger samples, could ultimately support therapists in the early identification of patients at risk of dropout and in proactively addressing disengagement.
Objective: Evidence for predictors of long-term outcomes in personality disorder (PD) treatment remains limited. Machine learning (ML) shows promise in early prediction of treatment outcome to inform clinical practice. This study evaluates the performance of various ML algorithms and examines variables that predict lon...
Johanna W. van den Eshof, Romy G. Leferink, Henricus L. Van et al.· Psychotherapy Research· 0 citations
Importance
Early identification of patients at high risk of relapse is key to personalized preventive strategies in major depressive disorder (MDD). However, current predictive models do not adequately account for the multimodal factors contributing to MDD relapse and fail to provide clinically meaningful predictions....
L. Teutenberg, N. Winter, P. Usemann et al.· JAMA psychiatry· 0 citations
These findings suggest that standard clinical variables may hold predictive value for early readmission in MDD, however, external validation, assessment of model calibration, and clinical utility are needed prior to clinical implementation.
F. Bartoli, M. Luciano, C. Crocamo et al.· Journal of Affective Disorde...· 0 citations
The current gold standard treatment for Hoarding Disorder (HD) is cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). However, typical symptom reduction is 25% and only about one third of individuals achieve a clinically meaningful response. We used machine learning (ML) to identify predictors of treatment response using data from a n...
Jessica J. Zakrzewski, Samantha Williams, Tara Hashemian et al.· Behaviour Research and Thera...· 0 citations
INTRODUCTION
Depression is prevalent in early psychosis and associated with poorer functional outcomes and suicide risk. Early identification of depression risk is critical to inform targeted interventions. This study aimed to develop models to predict depression risk using electronic health records (EHRs) from patient...
Sergio Mena, Dominic Oliver, F. Coutts et al.· Psychotherapy and Psychosoma...· 0 citations
Abstract Background Schizophrenia is a severe mental disorder characterized by high disability and relapse rates, posing significant challenges to public safety and community-based mental health management. Objective This study aimed to develop and validate a model for identifying hospitalization-related severe relapse...
Wei-Bo Zhang, Dian Zhu, Xiao-Lan Wang et al.· JMIR Medical Informatics· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.