Skip to content
Book Open access

Games of Diplomacy: Eliciting Spite Against Automated Opponents Through Structured Game Environments

Sep 2026 · International Conference on Intelligent Virtual Agents · pp. 1-9 · 0 citations · 15 references
Computer Science

TL;DR

This study successfully elicited spiteful behavior in human participants playing against an automated opponent compared to controls across all experimental conditions, and suggests that the decision to act spitefully may not be strongly influenced by associated costs and risks, contrary to initial hypotheses.

Abstract

Social games require a nuanced understanding of human behavior and are uniquely difficult to solve computationally, even with access to large behavioral datasets. Examining specific aspects of social gameplay, however, can simultaneously yield insight into human behavior and inform the design of more accurate, human-like artificial agents. Understanding and modeling human social behaviors is therefore central to the development of intelligent virtual agents, whether the objective is player profiling, game design, agent modeling, or robustness to diverse social behaviors. Previous research in social games and behavioral game theory has explored player types and factors such as social value orientation, but has often overlooked social emotions and behaviors like spite that deviate from classical rationality and yet are pervasive in competitive human interaction. This paper specifically examines spiteful behavior, a common but underexplored social phenomenon in the agent design literature. We use a variation of the board game Diplomacy as a controlled experimental environment to manipulate parameters such as risk and cost associated with spiteful actions. Our study successfully elicited spiteful behavior in human participants playing against an automated opponent compared to controls across all experimental conditions. Moreover, our findings suggest that the decision to act spitefully may not be strongly influenced by associated costs and risks, contrary to initial hypotheses. We discuss implications for the design of intelligent agents that must recognize, model, or reproduce spiteful behavior in service of more realistic and human-like social interaction.

Read PDF

Similar papers

#artificial intelligence Review Oct 2026

Fig: Automated Multiagent Behavior Elicitor

Many social evaluations for multiagent systems study behaviors as they emerge from environments instead of systematically intervening in the environment to elicit such behaviors. We introduce Fig (Finding Interactions in Games), an agentic system that performs targeted elicitation interventions on game environments. It...

An-Rui Gu, Zhi-Chao Wang, Nicolai Ouporov · 0 citations
Book Open access Nov 2026

Investigating Player Agency and Role Appeal in Asymmetric Cooperative Games

In recent years, cooperative multiplayer games have exploded in popularity due to its highly engaging gameplay by uniting players towards a common goal. Developers have thus started venturing into the asymmetric games’ genre, where players engage in different roles and objectives. This has resulted in the commercial su...

Jia Qian Peh, Renee Teo, Samantha Sze et al. · 0 citations

GameBoyWorlds: A Testbed for Self-Improvement in Embodied Video Games

GameBoyWorlds is introduced, a testbed for agentic self-improvement in video games and it is shown that contemporary approaches to self-improvement are lacking, with world modelling and autonomous skill discovery failing, and a novel strategy that uses curiosity-based exploration to write guides achieving only partial...

Dhananjay Ashok, Adam Shen, A. Feng et al. · 1 citation
Open access Oct 2026

Near-random behavior in strategic games.

Humans struggle to produce random behavior when asked to do so, leading some to suggest that our ability to randomize is attenuated (or even absent). Here, we demonstrate that the capacity for random behavior is much greater than previously acknowledged: Humans can behave in (near) optimally random ways when the contex...

Tal Boger, Dorsa Amir, S. Yousif · 0 citations
Review Open access Nov 2026

Gacha Impact: Systems, Characters, and the Player Experience of Gacha Games

Gacha games are a broad genre of games that feature monetized Random Reward Mechanisms (RRMs) as a core mechanic—known as the gacha. Gacha games have become increasingly prevalent and popular all across the world, and simultaneously controversial due to their monetization methods. Several studies have examined player m...

Angeleen Tan, Elín Carstensdóttir · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Asymmetric Gaming Further Apart: Effects of World and Goal Sharing on Cooperative Play

Asymmetric game design can create rich social experiences and foster inclusion by assigning players distinct, interdependent roles that cater to different needs and preferences. However, as this approach intentionally introduces differences between individual gameplay experiences, it raises questions about how far asym...

David Gonçalves, Daniel Reis, K. Gerling et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.