Skip to content

Geometric and operational determinants of motor vehicle-bicycle overtaking on Brazilian urban roads.

Aug 2026 · Traffic Injury Prevention · pp. 1-8 · 0 citations · 26 references
Medicine

Abstract

Objective

Overtaking maneuvers between motor vehicles and bicycles (OVB) represent a critical hazard for cyclists due to required lateral clearances and vehicle speeds. This study aims to evaluate the OVB process in urban environments, focusing on the main geometric and operational attributes that influence cyclists' objective road safety indicators.

Methods

A quasi-naturalistic observational study was conducted on urban roads in Fortaleza, Brazil, using an instrumented bicycle. Data on vehicle speed, lateral passing distance, lane configuration, vehicle type, and the presence of adjacent traffic were collected across 1,075 overtaking maneuvers. Statistical analyses were performed to assess the impact of these attributes on safety indicators.

Results

Analysis revealed that 76% of observed passing maneuvers violated the Brazilian national recommendation of maintaining a minimum lateral distance of 1.50 m. The presence of cycling infrastructure and the absence of traffic in adjacent lanes were significantly associated with greater passing distances. Furthermore, a behavioral compensatory threshold was identified at a 0.85-meter lateral distance: drivers modulated speed as a risk-mitigation mechanism only during critical clearances, whereas no speed adjustments were observed at the 1.50-meter legal threshold.

Conclusions

A vast majority of drivers fail to comply with recommended passing distances, highlighting the need for targeted infrastructure and operational interventions. The existence of dedicated cycling facilities effectively improves lateral separation. Moreover, drivers adapt speed only under extreme proximity (under 0.85 m), demonstrating that legal limits alone do not induce safer driver behavior without structural or physical support.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Jul 2026

Speed and Lane Change Characteristics of Motorcycles at Priority Junction

Motorcycles are Indonesia’s predominant mode of transportation and contribute to a substantial share of road traffic accidents. The research aims to identify key behavioural factors contributing to motorcycle-related conflict risks at intersections and to propose evidence-based safety interventions. This study analyzed speed characteristics with varying degrees of disruption that motorists would experience at the intersection. These disruptions were categorized into high, low, no disruption, and left-turn movements. High disruption was defined as vehicles stopping in the middle of the intersection as motorcyclists approached, while low disruption was defined as vehicles preparing to enter the intersection from minor roads. In addition to speed characteristics, this study also observed lane-changing behavior when disruptions occurred at the intersection. To obtain detailed data, drone-based cameras were used for observations, and the results were validated against radar speed measurements. The results show that 67.94% of riders exceed the 60 km/h speed limit during the morning period, while 33.27% exceed it in the afternoon, indicating clear temporal differences in operating speeds. Approximately 85 per cent of lane-changing manoeuvres occur within 20 metres of the conflict point, reflecting short decision distances that increase collision risk. Riders also exhibit assertive gap-acceptance behaviour, often requiring main-road vehicles to adjust their speed. Statistical validation confirms that there is no significant difference between drone-derived and radar-based speed measurements, demonstrating the reliability of the drone-based methodology. Based on these findings, the study recommends targeted speed management measures, including automated enforcement and the use of traffic-calming devices; improved lane discipline through more precise road markings and selective physical separation; and junction design enhancements, such as motorcycle waiting areas and advanced stop lines. These measures can improve motorcycle safety at priority junctions and support more efficient and predictable urban traffic operations.  

Benidiktus Susanto, Siti Malkhamah, Latif Budi Suparma et al. · 0 citations
Review Jul 2026

Bicyclist overtaking in naturalistic riding data: Speed, clearance, and implications for injury risk.

OBJECTIVE Motor vehicle passing speed and lateral clearance jointly determine both bicyclist injury risk and perceived safety during overtaking events. Most prior studies have examined these factors separately and/or in limited settings. Real-world evidence describing how passing speed and clearance interact across heterogeneous roadway contexts remains limited. This study evaluates high-resolution naturalistic overtaking data within a kinetic-energy injury framework to evaluate whether roadway context and bicycle infrastructure modify both passing speed and lateral clearance, and whether spatial compensation meaningfully offsets energetic exposure. METHODS Following institutional review board approval, naturalistic cycling data were collected from six commuter cyclists riding as normal using a sensor suite including cameras, lidar, rear-facing radar, GPS, and inertial measurement unit. Approximately 9,900 km of riding were recorded over four months. Overtaking events were detected and characterized using time-synchronized radar and lidar data, yielding 8,753 passes with reliable vehicle speed estimates after quality filtering. Overtaking events were map-matched to OpenStreetMap roadway attributes and supplemented with image-based manual coding to classify functional class, posted speed limit, lane count, centerline configuration, and bicycle infrastructure type. Ordinary least-squares regression models with participant-clustered standard errors were applied to evaluate infrastructure effects and speed-distance relationships, including interactions with driver speeding behavior. RESULTS Passing speed varied substantially across roadway contexts, increasing with functional class and posted speed limit. Mean passing speed ranged from approximately 10 m/s (residential roads) to nearly 15 m/s (primary and four-lane facilities). In contrast, lateral clearance varied modestly across contexts, with mean values generally between 2.2 and 3.0 m and substantial overlap among categories. After adjustment for roadway characteristics, standard painted bicycle lanes were associated with reduced passing distance (β = -0.31 m) and higher passing speed (β = +1.36 m/s) relative to roads without bicycle accommodation. Shoulders were associated with the highest passing speeds and no meaningful increase in clearance. The overall compensation slope, defined as the increase in lateral clearance with increasing speed, was small: 0.016 m per 1 m/s (∼2.8 inches per 10 mph). Modest but statistically significant compensation was observed among drivers exceeding the speed limit and on higher-speed, higher-capacity roadways. CONCLUSIONS Roadway context strongly influenced passing speed, whereas lateral clearance adjustments were comparatively small and inconsistent. Across various naturalistic environments, lateral clearance did not increase proportionally at higher speeds. On-road bicycle infrastructure without accompanying speed management did not reliably reduce high-speed passing and, in some contexts, was associated with closer overtaking. These findings demonstrate the need for vehicle speed reduction and improved separation of bicycles from motor vehicle traffic to reduce crash injury risk.

Laura Hamm, Marty Miller · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Assessing the Efficacy of Vertical Deflection Versus Visual Signalling in Urban Transition Zones: A Field Study on Speed Compliance

Managing vehicle speeds in rural-to-urban transition zones—where two-lane roads traverse small population centres—remains a critical challenge for road safety engineering. While various traffic calming measures (TCMs) are employed to enforce speed limits, empirical evidence comparing their relative effectiveness in sequential applications is often limited. This study presents a field analysis conducted on the BI-2604 road in Gordexola (Spain). Using radar counters at 24 sequential control points, a dataset of 23,021 valid vehicle passages was analysed to evaluate seven distinct calming configurations. The results indicate that, within this corridor, purely visual countermeasures were associated with high non-compliance: standard crosswalks (paint only) recorded a non-compliance rate of 92.9%, while the Speed Monitoring Display (SMD) registered a 72.1% violation rate. Regarding physical measures, a safety–compliance paradox was identified. Speed humps located in 50 km/h zones achieved the highest statistical compliance (41.7% violation). However, raised crosswalks in 30 km/h zones, despite registering higher non-compliance (63.6%), achieved the lowest mean speeds (approximately 34 km/h; V85 ≈ 45 km/h), a range that the previous literature associates with lower pedestrian injury risk. The findings suggest that, within the investigated corridor, physical vertical deflection was associated with lower speeds than the analysed visual/signalling measures, although it remains an imperfect solution that generates significant negative externalities (noise, emissions, and discomfort) and fails to guarantee strict legal adherence to 30 km/h limits. These limitations highlight the urgent need for alternative solutions, setting the stage for future research on optimised perceptual countermeasures.

Santiago Martin-Castresana, María Castro, Heriberto Pérez-Acebo · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Analyzing roadway factors influencing the severity of non-motorized road users' crashes in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA

As U.S. cities expand multimodal transportation networks and pursue Vision Zero goals, crash severity among pedestrians and bicyclists remains a critical public safety challenge. Charlotte, NC, offers a timely case study given its rapid urban growth, rising active transportation demand, and commitment to Vision Zero. This study investigates the human, behavioral, and environmental determinants of pedestrian and bicyclist crash severity in Charlotte, North Carolina, using a five-year crash dataset (2019–2023). Binary logistic regression was applied after evaluating and rejecting ordinal and multinomial approaches due to proportional odds violations and class imbalance. Two models were developed: a primary cause (behavioral) model and an environmental and primary cause model. Crash records were drawn from the Highway Safety Information System (HSIS), supplemented with historical weather data and site inspection to address missing values. The behavioral model found that crashes with no identified contributing circumstance had 2.32 times higher odds of severe injury compared to human-attributed crashes. This association is best interpreted as a crash-documentation artifact, as it attenuates to non-significance once road design and road-user type are controlled. The extended environmental model achieved an AUC of 0.78 (95% CI 0.74–0.82). Daylight reduced severe crash odds by 66%. Divided roads with positive median barriers increased severity risk more than twofold (OR = 2.52). Each additional travel lane raised severity odds by 18%. Urban locations and intersections were also statistically significant predictors, and bicyclists faced substantially lower severity odds than pedestrians (OR = 0.24). Infrastructure design (particularly road division, lane count, and lighting), is a stronger predictor of severe crash outcomes than behavioral fault assignment. Findings support targeted infrastructure interventions in Charlotte’s Vision Zero and active transportation planning efforts.

Fatemeh Abdous, R. Javid, Celeste Chavis et al. · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Riding behavior of delivery riders at unsignalized intersections: an observational study.

OBJECTIVE Professional delivery riders in China have experienced a sharp increase in traffic crashes, injuries, and fatality rates over recent years. This observational study sought to identify and analyze risk factors influencing riding behavior among electric bicycle delivery riders compared to other electric bicycle riders during potential conflicts at unsignalized intersections. METHODS Two typical unsignalized intersections in Nantong City with mixed traffic (pedestrians, motorized and non-motorized vehicles) were selected for observation. Through systematic video coding and analysis of 637 min of continuous video observations, we extracted a total of 1,558 potential conflict events, including interactions between electric bicycle riders and pedestrians, motorized vehicles, or non-motorized vehicles. Among these events, 394 occurred under congested traffic and 1,164 under free-flowing traffic. Data were analyzed via descriptive statistics, non-parametric chi-square tests and logistic regression. RESULTS (1) Under congested traffic conditions, delivery riders generally exhibited more pronounced hazardous riding behaviors than other riders, and such differences were more obvious among male and young delivery riders; (2) Regardless of road user type, delivery riders exhibited a high proportion (about 20%) of hazardous riding behaviors under both traffic conditions; (3) During potential conflicts with motor vehicles in congested traffic, delivery riders engaged in more hazardous riding than other riders; (4) Professional delivery riders engaged in risky behavior at a rate 1.88 times that of other riders. CONCLUSIONS For delivery riders at unsignalized intersections, hazardous riding behaviors are influenced by the combined effects of traffic conditions, rider demographic characteristics, and potential conflict objects. Professional delivery riders exhibit the highest risk levels under congested traffic conditions, particularly during potential conflicts with motor vehicles. Findings reflect the influence of occupational demands, such as tight delivery schedules, on delivery riders' riding strategies in various contexts.

Yunxin Chang, Jinnuo Li, Huarong Wang et al. · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Transport Infrastructure and Urban Mobility: A Data-Driven Evaluation of Bus Layby Impact on Expressway Efficiency

Expressways are designed to facilitate uninterrupted traffic flow; however, localized roadside features such as bus laybys disrupt vehicle dynamics and reduce operational capacity. While classical speed–density models provide theoretical foundations for freeway analysis, localized disturbances are frequently omitted from conventional modeling. This study evaluates the speed–density relationship of passenger cars on a basic expressway segment adjacent to a bus layby along the Federal Highway (KM 17) in Selangor, Malaysia. Traffic data were collected across peak and off-peak periods using elevated video recordings and analyzed via Tracker motion-analysis software across 36 five-minute intervals. Comparative evaluation against classical single-regime models demonstrated that the linear Greenshields model ($V_s = 116.97 - 1.381k$) provided the most robust fit, explaining 75.05% of the variation in passenger car speed ($R^2 = 75.05\%$, $F = 102.27$, $p < 0.001$). The empirical findings indicate that each 10-unit increase in density ($pcu/km$) induces an approximate 14 $km/h$ reduction in speed, largely driven by lane-changing turbulence and deceleration near the layby weave zone. These results underscore the need for infrastructure authorities to incorporate localized disturbance factors into expressway capacity planning and offer actionable insights for optimizing bus layby geometry and setback distances to preserve highway efficiency.

Ifham Fathi Sayuti, T. Besar, Noorazlan Hasnim et al. · 0 citations