Skip to content
Review

How ESG considerations shape consumer decisions: a comprehensive review using the TCCM framework

Jul 2026 · Journal of Strategy and Management · pp. 1-39 · 0 citations · 71 references

Abstract

Environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations have become increasingly relevant in shaping consumer attitudes, trust and purchasing behavior. Although related reviews have examined sustainability, corporate social responsibility, and emerging ESG-consumer trends, the literature remains fragmented and lacks a structured account of how ESG-consumer research is distributed across theories, contexts, characteristics, and methodologies. This study conducts a systematic literature review (SLR) to synthesize and map the evolving knowledge structure of research at the intersection of consumer behavior and ESG. Using the scientific procedures and rationales for systematic literature reviews (SPAR-4-SLR) protocol, this study systematically reviews 42 articles indexed in the Web of Science (WoS) and Scopus databases up to February 2025. Bibliometric analysis is used to identify publication trends, influential contributors, and thematic patterns, while the theory–context–characteristics–methodology (TCCM) framework is employed to interpret the field's theoretical foundations, contextual settings, characteristic features and methodological profile. This review shows that ESG-consumer research is growing rapidly but remains theoretically fragmented, geographically concentrated, and methodologically narrow. The literature is dominated by East Asian settings, especially South Korea and China, and is concentrated in service-oriented sectors such as food and beverage, tourism, hospitality, and sports. Corporate-centric and brand-related perspectives are prevalent, while consumer-centered theorization, cross-cultural evidence, and negative consumer responses such as skepticism remain underexplored. Methodologically, survey-based quantitative designs, particularly structural equation modeling, dominate the field, with limited use of qualitative, mixed-method, experimental, and longitudinal approaches. The review is limited to studies indexed in WoS and Scopus, potentially excluding relevant research published in other databases or non-English sources. The findings suggest that businesses should align ESG strategies with consumer expectations through credible, transparent and context-relevant communication, while policymakers should strengthen disclosure quality and accountability to reduce skepticism and greenwashing concerns. As consumers become more attentive to ESG-related information, their responses may reinforce more responsible consumption, stronger corporate accountability and wider demand for credible sustainability practices. This study extends prior reviews by moving beyond descriptive trend mapping and variable-based synthesis to provide an integrated account of the intellectual and empirical structure of ESG-consumer research. By combining bibliometric analysis with the TCCM framework, it offers a more systematic understanding of how the field has evolved, where its major imbalances lie, and what is needed for stronger theory development and future inquiry.

View source

Similar papers

Review Open access Aug 2026

BRIDGING THE INTENTION-BEHAVIOR GAP IN GREEN CONSUMER BEHAVIOR : TOWARD AN INTEGRATIVE FRAMEWORK

Objectives: This study seeks to analyze the factors and underlying mechanisms that influence green consumer behavior, while pinpointing significant conceptual deficiencies in the current literature. The emphasis is on sustainable consumption, highlighting the interaction among psychological, social, and contextual factors that influence consumer behavior. Methodology: A systematic literature review methodology was implemented, employing Publish or Perish (PoP), VOSviewer (VV), and the PRISMA 2020 framework to provide a transparent and organized selection process. A literature search utilizing keywords including green consumer behavior, green buying behavior, green purchase intention, sustainable consumption, and pro-environmental behavior yielded 200 articles from the Scopus database via PoP. The dataset was examined with VOSviewer to delineate research structures and patterns, and then underwent PRISMA screening, resulting in 25 pertinent empirical investigations. Findings:  The results demonstrate that human characteristics, psychological mechanisms, and contextual conditions are strongly interconnected in influencing green consumer behavior; however, their integration remains inadequate in existing research. Suggestion: This study fills this gap by presenting an integrated conceptual framework that provides a more thorough, contextually relevant understanding of green consumer behavior.

Annisa Wahyuni Arsyad, Lucky Brando Punu, Eirene Copalcanty Tuko et al. · 0 citations
Review Jul 2026

Internal marketing: a systematic literature review and research agendas

Extant literature highlights the significance of internal marketing (IM) for enhancing organizational performance. Although it spans both the domains of marketing and human resource (HR), IM remains under-researched. There is a need for a structured, systematic literature review (SLR) to synthesize IM literature. By applying the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses and theory–context–characteristics–methodology framework, this SLR synthesizes 170 selected research papers to explore the nuances of IM and its implications. The review identified varied research gaps, categorized as contextual, digital/technological, strategic, crisis and cultural, and suggests future research propositions. It identifies multifaceted themes of IM literature and offers theoretical contributions. The framework highlights the varied IM practices. The resultant benefits include the role of digitization, artificial intelligence (AI) and sustainability as moderators. The review contributes theoretically by analysing different theoretical frameworks, such as social exchange theory, social identity theory, transformative learning theory and socio-technical system theory, which extend insights into the role of IM in shaping employee attitude and behaviour conducive to organizational success. The review offers insights into managerial implications. The outcome would help managers implement effective IM practices, including training, proper communication and reward systems with the integration of digitalization and AI, which will foster employee satisfaction, loyalty, commitment and performance. The review attempts to conduct a structured review of research on IM. Synthesizing extant IM literature, it presents a conceptual framework that exhibits the relationship between varied IM practices and the outcomes related to organizations, employees, customers and society.

Malabika Sahoo, B. Rup, Justin Paul et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

ESG, global compact and 2030 agenda: framework proposal based on social marketing and transformative consumer research

Purpose: This study proposes a framework to systematize the relationships among Social Marketing, Transformative Consumer Research (TCR), and sustainable practices (ESG, Global Compact, and the 2030 Agenda). The framework highlights their respective strengths, weaknesses, and implications for sustainable development, drawing on state-of-the-art literature and outlining a future research agenda with both academic and managerial applications. Design/Methodology/Approach: The research employs conceptual analysis grounded in a systematic literature review focused on sustainable management practices through the perspectives of Social Marketing and TCR. The SPAR-4-SLR protocol served as the systematic review method, guiding research planning, knowledge expansion, and supporting critical reflection within the current state of the field. Findings: Analysis of 81 articles revealed a predominance of quantitative methodologies and an increase in publications in 2023 and 2024. Notable gaps include definitional, measurement, and implementation issues in sustainable practices, particularly the absence of standardized ESG metrics, limited applicability of the Global Compact to small enterprises, and challenges surrounding the local adaptation of the 2030 Agenda. Originality/Value: The proposed framework integrates Social Marketing and TCR with sustainable practices, elucidating how ESG, the Global Compact, and the 2030 Agenda can facilitate transformation in consumer behavior and support the alignment of organizations with socio-environmental demands. It identifies strengths, weaknesses, research gaps, and proposes a future research agenda. The analysis emphasizes the need for standardized metrics and collaborative approaches to progress sustainable development.

Ana Lígia Gil Espuny Machado, Stefânia Ordovás de Almeida, Otávio José de Oliveira · 0 citations
Review Jul 2026

Greenwashing in Corporate Disclosures: A Systematic Review, an Integrated Framework and Future Research Agenda

Greenwashing refers to the practice whereby organizations make misleading or deceptive claims about their products, services or operations to influence consumer perceptions and attract customers. Given the growing scholarly interest in greenwashing, this study presents a hybrid systematic review of greenwashing in corporate disclosures by integrating bibliometric and framework-based analyses. The SPAR-4-SLR protocol guided the systematic review process for assembling, arranging and evaluating the literature. To achieve the research objectives, a bibliometric analysis was first conducted. The findings were subsequently synthesized using the actor-antecedents-decisions-outcomes (AADO) framework along with the theoretical, contextual, and methodological (TCM) frameworks, leading to the development of an integrative framework on greenwashing in corporate disclosures. The framework on greenwashing in corporate disclosures outlines the primary actors and their evolving roles, while synthesizing the key antecedents, decisions and outcomes alongside the dominant theories, contextual dimensions and methodological approaches. Finally, the study presents future research agenda and highlights key areas for further study.

Jaymol Mary Joseph, Shikha Bhatia · 0 citations
Review Jul 2026

Environmental, Social, and Governance: A Systematic Literature Review and Research Agenda

Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) principles have become essential for companies seeking to avoid greenwashing and promote genuine sustainability practices. This study aims to identify the practices, barriers, and strategies for adopting ESG as a competitive strategy. A systematic literature review was conducted, which included a bibliometric analysis of 496 documents. This generated four clusters, with content analysis applied to 20 documents presenting the highest PageRank per cluster, for a total of 80 documents. The clusters are (i) innovation and green performance, (ii) influence on corporate and financial performance, (iii) communication and transparency, and (iv) diverse governance and corporate sustainability. For every cluster, the practices, barriers, and strategies for adopting ESG principles were analyzed. In addition, a research agenda was developed with questions for future research and methodological suggestions. Finally, a framework with the main practices is presented so that companies and decision‐makers can adopt ESG as a competitive strategy.

Heloísa Serafim Kuakoski, F. H. Lermen, G. Lenzi et al. · 0 citations