Skip to content
Open access

03 | Simulation learning process for medical students: quality evaluation study

Jul 2026 · Emergency Care Journal · Vol 22 · 0 citations

TL;DR

These findings support the integration of simulation-based learning as a core component of healthcare education, emphasizing its practical, realistic approach as essential for meaningful, hands-on learning.

Abstract

Background. Simulation-based learning is an effective strategy for developing technical, decision-making, and communication skills in clinical contexts [1,2]. A simulation course was recently introduced at the University of Salento for medical and nursing students. It aimed to foster both soft and hard skills through low-fidelity mannequin scenarios. At the end of the course, a questionnaire was administered to assess perceived educational effectiveness, professional relevance, and course organization. Methods. The overall sample includes 260 students (80 medical, 180 nursing). This report presents preliminary findings from 180 nursing students. The questionnaire, comprising closed and open-ended questions, explored perceived usefulness, learning ease, clarity of objectives, instructor preparation, professional applicability, and personal impact. Data were collected anonymously and analyzed using percentage frequencies. Results. As shown in Figure 1, 88% of students considered the course “extremely useful” for improving clinical skills; 12% rated it as “very useful.” Additionally, 72% found mannequin-based sessions “extremely useful.” For learning purposes, 88% judged the simulation course “very useful,” and 13% “useful.”   Regarding ease of learning (Figure 2) 47% found the topics “very easy,” 30% “easy,” and 21% “fairly easy” with the adopted methodology. Educational objectives were considered “very clear” by 96% of participants, and 100% acknowledged a high level of instructor preparation. Overall, 62% reported that the course exceeded their expectations. For life-saving technique acquisition, 47% rated it “very easy,” 30% “easy,” and 21% “fairly easy,” indicating the effectiveness of active learning methods. Regarding clinical relevance, 95% rated the course as “very important.” In terms of personal development, 64% reported a “very” positive impact, while 30% rated it “quite positive.” Open-ended responses revealed strong interest in further training on pediatric/neonatal resuscitation and electrocardiogram interpretation. Students also suggested increasing simulation sessions and adopting peer learning methodologies. Conclusions. The questionnaire confirmed high student satisfaction and perceived instructional effectiveness. These findings support the integration of simulation-based learning as a core component of healthcare education, emphasizing its practical, realistic approach as essential for meaningful, hands-on learning.  

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access 2026

Simulation-Based Learning, Peer Collaboration and Clinical Confidence Levels of Nursing Students

A well-structured nursing curriculum plays a crucial role in shaping competent healthcare professionals by integrating theoretical knowledge with hands-on clinical practice. This study investigated simulation-based learning, peer collaboration, and the confidence levels of nursing students in the clinical setting. The study utilized a quantitative approach, specifically a descriptive correlational design. It was conducted to Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN) program in the first congressional district of Zamboanga Del Sur. The respondents of the study were 120 nursing students, selected using the total enumeration sampling technique. Researcher-made instrument tools were used to conduct the study, namely the Level of Simulation-Based Learning, Level of Peer Collaboration, and Level of Confidence. Frequency and percentage, mean and standard deviation, and the Pearson Product-Moment Correlation Coefficient (Pearson's r) are the statistical procedures applied. The findings show that respondents' levels of simulation-based learning is very high. The respondents peer collaboration is also very high. Additionally, respondents demonstrated a generally high level of confidence. There is a highly significant relationship between respondents’ level of simulation-based learning performance and their level of confidence as well as between peer collaboration and level of confidence across various constructs. Three key predictors contribute to student level of confidence: a realistic environment, feedback and reflection, and shared responsibility. Students' self confidence in their ability to learn was shaped by a realistic atmosphere, feedback and reflection, and shared accountability. It is recommended that the institution adopt high-fidelity simulation-based learning to further strengthen the integration of simulation-based learning across all educational programs.

Mary Darline Denosca, Judy Jane S. Revelo · 0 citations
Review Mar 2026

Simulation-Based Learning in a Resource-Limited Setting: Perspectives of Clinical Medical Students in North-Western Nigeria.

Background: Simulation-based learning (SBL) is an emerging educational methodology that actively engages students and helps bridge the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical clinical skills. It allows students to learn in realistic clinical scenarios using manikins and trained actors (standardized patients) in a controlled learning environment. Well-designed simulation exercises can enhance both technical and non-technical competencies among medical students. This study aimed to assess the knowledge, attitudes, and perceptions of clinical medical students toward simulation-based learning at Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, North-Western Nigeria. Methodology: A descriptive cross-sectional study design was employed. Data were collected using a pretested, structured, closed-ended, self-administered questionnaire. A total of 138 clinical medical students of Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, were selected using a stratified random sampling technique. Data were analyzed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 25.0, and results were presented using tables and charts. Associations between categorical variables were assessed using the Chi-square test, with statistical significance set at p < 0.05. Results: The mean age of the respondents was 24.76 ± 1.93 years. More than two-thirds (70.3%) of the respondents had good knowledge of SBL, while the majority demonstrated positive perceptions (90.6%) and positive attitudes (92.7%) toward simulation-based learning. A statistically significant association was observed between attitude and perception toward simulation-based learning as a method of clinical training. Conclusion: The findings indicate that most respondents possessed good knowledge of simulation-based learning and expressed positive attitudes and perceptions toward its use. The majority were satisfied with SBL as a teaching method. Therefore, simulation-based learning should be incorporated into the medical school curriculum to enhance clinical training.

Jamilu Garba, Bilkisu Muazu Adam, A. Bello et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Jul 2026

Impact of Simulation-Based Learning on Problem-Solving Skills in Nursing Education

The findings support the integration of simulation-based strategies into nursing curricula as an effective approach to bridging the theory-practice gap and preparing students for safe and competent clinical practice.

Pratibha Thakur, Komal Kumari · 0 citations
Open access Jul 2026

EFFECTIVENESS OF COMPETENCY-BASED ASSESSMENT VERSUS TRADITIONAL ASSESSMENT IN UNDERGRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION

Background: Assessment processes are integral to the needs for achieving undergraduate medical students of knowledge, clinical skills, professional behavior, and decision making for independent practice. Traditional Assessment methods tend to be based on set and regular written/verbal/clinical assessments, while competency assessment focuses on real-life working, repeated evaluation, observation, feedback and demonstration of predefined competencies. The objective of this study was to compare competency-based assessment with traditional assessment among undergraduate medical students. Methods: A comparative study was conducted at Gomal Medical College, Dera Ismail Khan, from January 2025 to June 2025. Ninety-two undergraduate medical students were included, half of whom (46) were assessed using a competency-based method, and the other half (46) using the traditional method. Assessment results showed that general performance, written examination, clinical examination, workplace assessment, clinical reasoning skills, patient management, patient safety, patient satisfaction, clinical confidence and self-directed learning were the most commonly assessed items. Items that were most frequently assessed included general performance, written examination, clinical examination, workplace assessment, clinical reasoning skills, patient management, patient safety, patient satisfaction, clinical confidence, and self-directed learning. The data were analysed by SPSS version 25.0. Independent-samples t-test, chi-square test, Fisher's exact test and binary logistic regression were used appropriately. The criteria for statistical significance was defined as a p value of <0.05. Results: Students assessed through the competency-based approach achieved a significantly higher mean overall assessment score than those assessed traditionally (81.63 ± 6.42 vs. 75.28 ± 7.11, p < 0.001). Significant improvements were also observed in clinical examination performance, workplace-based assessment, clinical reasoning, clinical decision-making, procedural competence, communication, professionalism, teamwork, patient management, and patient-safety competencies. Feedback quality and student satisfaction were significantly greater in the competency based group. Satisfactory competency was achieved by 89.1% of students in the competency-based group compared with 67.4% in the traditional group (p = 0.012), while remediation was less frequent in the competency-based group (8.7% vs. 26.1%, p = 0.028). After adjustment for age, gender, and academic year, competency-based assessment remained independently associated with satisfactory competency achievement (adjusted OR = 3.68; 95% CI: 1.18 11.46; p = 0.025). Conclusion: Competency-based assessment was associated with better academic and clinical performance, stronger competency achievement, improved feedback, and greater student satisfaction compared with traditional assessment. Incorporating structured competency-based assessment into undergraduate medical education may support the development of clinical competence and provide a more comprehensive evaluation of student learning.

Sadaf Rasheed, Junaid Sarfaraz, Ayesha Junaid · 0 citations
Open access 2026

From the microscope to meaningful learning: Medical students’ perceptions of pathology teaching

ABSTRACT Introduction: Pathology education is fundamental in medical training as it integrates knowledge from both basic and clinical cycles. It is traditionally conducted through lectures and practical laboratory sessions. However, active learning, using flipped classroom, case-based learning, and gamification, centered on the student, has increasingly transformed this scenario. Objective: To evaluate medical students’ satisfaction and perception regarding the use of active learning strategies in Pathology teaching. Methods: A cross-sectional observational study was conducted at a Higher Education Institution between March and April 2025, after approval by the Research Ethics Committee (CAAE 86813724.6.0000.5580). A total of 201 students from the 3rd to the 8th semesters participated. Data were collected through a structured electronic questionnaire composed of five thematic blocks using a Likert scale, in addition to an open-ended comment field. Quantitative analysis included relative frequencies, chi-square test, and ordinal logistic regression (p < 0,05). For qualitative analysis of discourse exploration, content analysis according to Minayo was performed, including pre-analysis (floating reading), categorization, and interpretation of open-ended responses. Results: High acceptance of active learning strategies was observed, with agreement rates exceeding 84% in all blocks. Ordinal regression showed a significant association of overall satisfaction with Structure and Engagement (p < 0,001), Methodological Aspects (p = 0,018), and Feedback and Evaluation (p = 0,010). Qualitative analysis of the comments identified four themes: faculty appreciation, didactic clarity, practical classes and the use of microscopy, and suggestions for improvement. Students highlighted admiration for the professors, we-structured lessons, and the relevance of laboratory practices with histopathological slides. Suggestions emphasized interest in greater integration between theory and practice, demonstrating student engagement and active participation in the learning process. Conclusion: Students demonstrated high satisfaction with Pathology teaching and the active learning strategies employed. Didactic structure, faculty engagement, and methodological clarity were key factors for a positive perception of the teaching-learning process. Continuous improvement in assessment methods and the practical application of content is recommended to strengthen meaningful learning and the link between theory and medical practice.

Samya Hamad Mehanna, Rafaela Pires Erthal Michelato, Eduardo Morais de Castro · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Effectiveness of Return Demonstration on Enhancing Related Learning Experience Skills and Clinical Performance among Nursing Students at Dr. Carlos S. Lanting College

The purpose of this study was to investigate the efficacy of return demonstration in improving associated learning experience skills and clinical performance among nursing students at Dr. Carlos S Lanting College. It specifically evaluated students' self-confidence and clinical competence in performing nursing procedures, applying theoretical knowledge, making clinical decisions, communicating, and managing clinical duties. A quantitative study design was used, with a structured questionnaire as the major data collection tool. The respondents were nursing students, and the statistical methods used were the frequency and percentage, weighted mean average (WAM) and Cronbach's Alpha to analyze the data and verify instrument reliability. The study found that the return demonstration greatly increased students' relevant learning experience skills and clinical performance. Respondents reported excellent levels of self-confidence and clinical performance, indicating that the technique adequately prepares individuals for real-world clinical situations. The study concludes that return demonstration is an effective teaching method in nursing education. It is advised that educators continue to strengthen their implementation and that institutions allocate enough resources to facilitate student learning and skill development.

Abenaza Jeremy Charles T, Liwag Erika Lyka C, Llagas Cyril Ann U et al. · 0 citations