Skip to content
Open access

The Psychology of Artistic Authenticity

Jul 2026 · Empirical Studies of the Arts · 0 citations · 59 references

Abstract

In a world of deepfakes, generative AI, and ongoing debates over cultural appropriation, questions about what makes art “authentic” are newly urgent. We build on work from science and the humanities to offer a unified psychological account of perceived art authenticity . Across six studies, we find that people see art as more authentic when it appears to reveal a mind—a creator's lived experience, emotions, and intentions. The importance of “revealed mind” helps clarify central debates surrounding authenticity, explaining why replicas can sometimes feel authentic, and why audiences celebrate art that reflects an artist's lived experience and grow outraged when an artist tells someone else's story. Perceptions of revealed mind are especially important in the age of AI, explaining why AI-generated art feels inauthentic even when technically impressive. Together, our findings suggest that art feels most authentic when it evokes a sense of connection to the artist's mind.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Aug 2026

The authenticity of the visual image: contextualising the art infusion effect

The concept of art infusion suggests the application of authentically perceived, culturally congruent imagery, can have a positive influence upon consumer perceptions and evaluations. Although identified as a contemporary marketing activity, this paper demonstrates how art infusion remains a 17th century visual con...

P. Freathy, Iris Thomas · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Ideal Image and Technical Intervention: A Study of Liking What You See: A Documentary from the Perspective of Jung Archetype Theory

Ted Chiangss works have attracted widespread critical attention for their exploration of humanity and philosophical questions from the perspective of science fiction, with Story of Your Life being one of his most representative works. Among his writings, Liking What You See: A Documentary explores the complex relations...

Jia-He Yang · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Art Is the Evidence

Art-based research uses artmaking as a mode of inquiry and presents the art as evidence. While sharing many qualities with science, it is distinguished by the unique character of each expression and personal dimensions that must also transcend their creators in establishing relevance to others. Artistic intelligence i...

S. McNiff · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Narrating Authenticity: Meaning-Making and Boundary Negotiation in the Outsider Art World

Authenticity plays a crucial role in the legitimation and valorization within the cultural field. This study examines outsider art, a category labeled as “identity art” and characterized by a “culture of authenticity.” Based on data collected from 104 galleries and studios, it employs the narrative approach to analyze...

Fan-Ting Cheng · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Visual artists’ perspectives on the artist's statement: Negotiating language, identity, and legitimacy

This study investigates contemporary visual artists’ perceptions of the artist's statement, focusing on its role, functions, and influence on creative practice. Although the artist's statement has become a near-obligatory component of professional artmaking, previous research has largely prioritised textual or theo...

Darryl Hocking · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Imagining the Relational Through Speculative Fiction: Survival, Possibility, and Creativity

The concept of “imagination” has a complex role within the field of International Relations (IR). IR scholars are often trained to be grounded in “realities,” whether historical facts or data points. In IR scholarship, we see occasional calls for imaginative approaches and even to take fictional works seriously as reso...

Daniel Clausen · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.