Defining leadership competencies for rural community-based medicine: a Delphi study and field-based curriculum evaluation for undergraduate medical students
Abstract
Leadership is essential in community-based medicine, yet inconsistently taught in Japan’s undergraduate medical curricula. This study aimed to: (1) identify essential community-based leadership competencies using a Delphi approach, (2) develop and pilot a structured curriculum, and (3) evaluate outcomes through a multi-day interprofessional field programme. We adopted Kern’s six-step approach to curriculum development. A literature review extracted preliminary competencies. A two-round Delphi study was implemented with 61 community-based physician leaders in Kagoshima Prefecture, Japan. Round 1 evaluated 26 competencies on necessity, difficulty, and timing (four-point Likert scale; N = 26); Round 2 confirmed 14 revised competencies via dichotomous agreement ( N = 16). Internal consistency was assessed with Cronbach’s α and McDonald’s ω; content validity was assessed with Lawshe’s CVR. A half-day pilot course was then implemented for six medical students. Subsequently, a multi-day interprofessional training camp ( N = 26 reflective reports; N = 11 survey respondents) integrating agricultural field experience, resident interviews, SWOT-based community planning, and interprofessional group work was evaluated through qualitative category analysis of free-text reflective reports and a five-item Likert-scale survey. The Delphi study confirmed 14 leadership competencies across four domains. The pilot course revealed transformative shifts in students’ leadership perceptions. In the training camp evaluation, all 14 Delphi-derived competencies were represented in student reports; A1’ (Understanding others, 81%) and D3’ (Local profile analysis and issue identification, 62%) were most frequently observed. Survey items showed high endorsement rates (four-to-five-point responses: 91–100%), with ethnography (M = 4.27) rated marginally higher than SWOT analysis (M = 4.09) as a tool for community understanding. Qualitative analysis further revealed six competency dimensions not captured by the existing 14—notably social capital utilization (54%), SDH clinical integration (50%), and community engagement (46%)—suggesting directions for framework expansion. This study identified and validated 14 leadership competencies specific to community-based medicine and developed a corresponding curriculum. Field-based learning integrating medical anthropological approaches and SWOT analysis demonstrated robust alignment with the established competencies while revealing emergent competency domains. The proposed expanded framework—incorporating social capital, SDH, and place-based medicine—may inform broader efforts to integrate comprehensive leadership training into undergraduate and postgraduate medical education.