A Requirement-Driven Expert System for Blockchain Consensus Mechanism Selection

Abstract

Blockchain technology has introduced a rapidly expanding range of consensus mechanisms, each designed to satisfy different operational requirements related to security, scalability, decentralization, transaction throughput, and energy efficiency. Selecting an appropriate consensus mechanism has consequently become a complex multi-criteria decision problem, particularly for developers and organizations without extensive expertise in distributed systems and blockchain architectures. Existing tools primarily address protocol benchmarking and static documentation, leaving the decision-support dimension largely unaddressed. This paper presents a web-based expert system designed to support the selection of blockchain consensus mechanisms according to specific user-defined operational requirements. The proposed solution was implemented using the MERN technology stack, consisting of MongoDB, Express.js, React, and Node.js, enabling a modular and scalable architecture suitable for future expansion and maintenance. The recommendation process is based on a two-phase filtering and scoring algorithm. In the first phase, mechanisms incompatible with mandatory user-defined constraints, including network type and key resource type, are systematically eliminated. In the second phase, the remaining mechanisms are ranked using attribute matching across criteria encompassing energy efficiency, scalability, security, decentralization, and transaction speed. The system returns the three most suitable consensus mechanisms for the given operational scenario together with their key characteristics. In addition to recommendation functionality, the application supports user authentication, recommendation history management, and administrative maintenance of the consensus mechanism database, which currently contains 38 distinct blockchain consensus protocols. Experimental evaluation through twelve representative usage scenarios demonstrated that the system consistently produces contextually relevant recommendations aligned with user-specified requirements. A comparative analysis with existing tools confirms that the proposed system occupies a distinct decision-support role currently absent from the available tooling landscape. A comparative analysis against four representative existing tools indicates that the proposed system combines a set of decision-support capabilities not jointly offered by any one of them. The presented approach contributes a transparent and extensible decision-support framework intended to simplify architectural planning and management of blockchain-based distributed systems.