‘It Is Your Eating Disorder Talking’: A Focus Group Study of Patients' Experience of Alliance Ruptures in Psychiatric Treatment for Eating Disorders
Abstract
Treatments for eating disorders (EDs) are often inadequate, and dropout rates are among the highest within psychiatry. The quality of the therapeutic alliance has proven associated with treatment outcome, but forming and maintaining a strong alliance during ED treatment often presents difficulties. This study aimed to enrich our understanding of ruptures in the alliance during psychiatric ED treatment by bringing together individuals with lived experience and exploring episodes of rupture they considered important. Using focus groups, we interviewed 16 adults who had received psychiatric treatment for anorexia nervosa, atypical anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa and/or atypical bulimia nervosa. We analysed transcripts using Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis and validated findings by member‐checking. Four main themes emerged: (1) ‘Your rules and regulations are more rigid than eating disorders’, (2) ‘Then I am lost’, (3) ‘Could you bother seeing me?’ and (4) ‘If I ever had to be treated there again, I would rather not be alive’. Additional subthemes were identified for themes one and three. Findings suggest that a directive treatment culture with inflexible application of interventions can undermine the alliance and contribute to iatrogenic harm in ED treatment. Ruptures associated with iatrogenic harm appeared in relation to experiences with epistemic injustice, infringement of personal boundaries in intimate situations and non‐supportive reactions to disclosure of trauma. The pattern of negative experiences could resemble institutional betrayal and requires further attention in both clinical practice and research.