It is suggested that raw control‐forecast predictors, when used without prior postprocessing, do not necessarily provide useful information beyond the raw ensemble.
Abstract
Forecasting the hourly probability of precipitation (PoP) remains a persistent challenge, particularly across varying precipitation regimes and at fine temporal resolution. This study evaluates whether a recently proposed machine‐learning‐based postprocessing framework based on the use of available raw control forecast predictors in complementing the ensemble predictions can be robustly extended to a larger spatial domain and a full annual cycle. Using the European Centre for Medium‐Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) ensemble and control forecast data at 0.1° resolution, probabilistic precipitation forecasts are generated for 25 stations in Latvia over the period from 1 March 2023 to 29 February 2024. Three supervised machine‐learning classifiers—logistic regression, random forest, and a neural network—are trained daily to produce baseline (‘Base’) PoP predictions. Predictor selection is performed using a custom cross‐validation scoring function designed to avoid probability collapse in rare‐event regimes. Across most stations, lead times, and seasons, all Base methods exhibit lower skill than the raw ECMWF ensemble, as assessed by Brier skill score (BSS), Brier score (BS) timelines, receiver characteristic operation (ROC) curves, and contingency metrics. Apparent improvements during summer months are primarily associated with systematic under‐forecasting in low‐frequency precipitation regimes rather than enhanced discrimination. Motivated by temporal persistence observed in hourly precipitation, a secondary postprocessing step is introduced. A neural network trained on sliding temporal windows of Base predictions and raw ensemble predictors produces revised (‘Post’) forecasts. Post predictions demonstrate improved calibration, reduced false alarm ratios, and positive BSS values for most stations, particularly during drier months. However, the overall gains are modest and largely reflect probability dampening rather than consistent improvements in event detection. These results suggest that raw control‐forecast predictors, when used without prior postprocessing, do not necessarily provide useful information beyond the raw ensemble.
Subseasonal-to-seasonal precipitation forecasts are highly relevant for a wide range of practical applications and risk management, but their skill decreases substantially at longer lead times. Although statistical post-processing is widely regarded as a key step for improving forecast reliability, the skill of post-pr...
Ze-Qing Huang, Han-Jie Shen, Eun-Soon Im et al.· Stochastic environmental res...· 0 citations
This research establishes that with robust, automated feature engineering, modern machine learning models can explain approximately 68% of the variance in daily precipitation, providing a valuable and rigorously validated tool for a wide range of hydrological applications and setting a realistic performance benchmark.
Tevfik Denizhan Müftüoğlu· Osmaniye Korkut Ata Üniversi...· 0 citations
Accurate daily precipitation forecasting is a prerequisite for efficient reservoir operations, irrigation scheduling, and urban flood management, yet inherent predictability limits pose a significant challenge. This study quantifies these limits by evaluating a suite of seven machine learning models for one-day-ahead...
The skillful prediction of seasonal extreme precipitation anomalies is especially critical for agricultural planning, water resource allocation and flood mitigation. While single‐model deterministic dynamical systems are inherently limited in prediction skill and uncertainty quantification, the probabilistic predicti...
Wen-Rui Tang, Jie Wu, H. Ren et al.· International Journal of Cli...· 0 citations
The analysis reveals a transition from deterministic DI models to hybrid, physics-informed, uncertainty-aware, and operational forecasting systems that increasingly integrate AI with physical knowledge and heterogeneous environmental observations.
Braiton U. Mukhalela, S. Viriri, D. Ndzi et al.· Frontiers in Artificial Inte...· 0 citations
Atmospheric river (AR)-driven flooding is a natural hazard that causes severe damage in many regions, and the damage escalates sharply once an AR persists beyond a certain duration. Existing studies and numerical weather prediction models, however, have focused mainly on AR occurrence and on the intensity of integrated...
H. Chung, Cheong-Gi Kim· Water· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.