Skip to content

Strange and Whimsical Performances: William Smellie, Alexander Gillies, and the Paratexts to A Treatise of Modern Faulconry

Sep 2026 · Library · Vol 27, pp. 359 - 387 · 0 citations · 2 references

Abstract

Abstract:James Campbell's A Treatise of Modern Faulconry appeared in 1773, accompanied by an anonymous Preface and a long, anonymous Introduction. The Preface ignores the Treatise and offers a burlesque of the first volume of Lord Monboddo's The Origin and Progress of Language; the Introduction offers fantastic tales of falconry that scarcely resemble the actual practice. This essay argues that the Preface was written by Alexander Gillies, a Presbyterian minister, and the Introduction by William Smellie, the printer and natural historian. However, authorial attribution is but one portion of the story. It is shown that both men had some antipathy to falconry, that Gillies held deep reasons for challenging the thought of Monboddo, and that Smellie maintained long-standing concerns about the treatment of animals. In this way, these paratexts also enter eighteenth-century debates on the status of the human and the animal.

View source

Similar papers

Review Sep 2026

The Age of Subtlety: Nature and Rhetorical Conceits in Early Modern Europe by Javier Patiño Loira (review)

The Age of SubTleTy is guided by the fundamental question, “How do the operations of conceits relate to nature’s operations?” (184), and by the key premise that the early modern conceit ( conceptus , concetto , concepto ) took shape in tandem with contemporary shifts in scientific sensibilities. In developing his analy...

Chen-Yu Li · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Text, Stage, and Page: Garrick, Johnson, and the Editing of Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream in the Eighteenth Century

This article examines two contemporary eighteenth-century editions of A Midsummer Night’s Dream by William Shakespeare: David Garrick’s stage adaptation (1763) and Samuel Johnson’s critical edition (1765). Challenging the view that textual variation is primarily explained by chronological distance from the moment of au...

Paula Baldwin Lind · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Telling a Different Story: Grace Tiffany’s Ariel (2005)

Set in the Bermuda Triangle, Grace Tiffany’s novel Ariel (published in 2005) originally appropriates the Shakespearean romance, providing a long prequel to the hypotext’s dramatized events and rewriting its story. The novel centres on Ariel, whose origin is now that of a spirit born from the hallucinated brain of a Jew...

L. Calvi · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Lying Like Truth: Equivocation, Witchcraft, and the Unstable Self in Shakespeare's Macbeth

Macbeth is Shakespeare's shortest tragedy and, by common consent, his most concentrated study of a mind in the act of undoing itself. This article argues that the play's famous linguistic doubleness its riddling prophecies, its paradoxes of fair and foul, its obsession with words that mean two things at once is not mer...

Manjula K. T. · 0 citations
Open access 2026

“Digression in Praise of the Ass” by Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa von Nettesheim in Dostoevsky’s The Idiot

In his early youth, Dostoevsky recognized a single life purpose for himself: to comprehend the mystery of man and the mystery of God. Such a life’s task inevitably presupposed an engagement with the books of the European esoteric tradition and, consequently, their functional presence in the writer’s works. In particula...

Tatyana A. Kasatkina · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.