Skip to content
Open access

Between Danda and Dharma: The Indian Knowledge System and the Long Conversation on Statecraft from Kautilya to the Early Modern Courts

Sep 2026 · Contemporary Social Science · 0 citations · 54 references

Abstract

Scholarship on the history of political thought has long treated systematic reflection on power as a Graeco-Roman inheritance transmitted through Renaissance Europe, a framing that marginalizes the Indian subcontinent’s substantial and continuous engagement with the theory and practice of rule. This article addresses that gap by reconstructing the intellectual history of statecraft within the Indian Knowledge System from the late centuries BCE to the early modern period. Drawing on critical editions and scholarly translations of Sanskrit, Pali, Persian, Tamil and Telugu sources, and on the secondary literature that has accumulated since the recovery of Kautilya’s Arthashastra in 1905, it examines four interrelated domains: the conceptual vocabulary of arthashastra, dandaniti, rajadharma and niti; competing theories of the origin of political authority, encompassing coercive, contractual and electoral accounts; the analytical apparatus of the Arthashastra, particularly the seven constituents of the state and the mandala theory of interstate relations; and the subsequent diversification of political thought across Brahmanical, Buddhist, Jain, Indo-Persian and vernacular traditions. Three findings emerge. First, the Indian tradition articulated a coherent theory of political obligation grounded in the state’s function of preventing predation among unequals. Second, the apparent opposition between realist and dharmic conceptions of kingship reflects a historical process of textual redaction rather than an enduring civilisational dichotomy. Third, medieval Indo-Persian and vernacular writing sustained, rather than displaced, the recognition that governance requires a distinct form of knowledge. The article argues that the tradition’s significance lies in its unresolved contestation over the reconciliation of effective rule with justice, and that its scholarly recovery requires philological rigour rather than commemorative endorsement.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.