Skip to content
Open access

Strength of developmental carry-over varies continuously with environmental conditions in a wild bird population

Sep 2026 · bioRxiv · 0 citations · 3 references
Biology

Abstract

Early-life phenotypes frequently predict adult phenotypes through developmental ‘silver-spoon’ carry-over effects, but how strongly and under what circumstances? Using 40 years of individual-based data from a great tit (Parus major) population, we used covariance reaction norms to understand how the natal-to-adult body mass association shifts across temperature, rainfall, and population density gradients during both life stages. We show that the natal–adult mass correlation is substantial (r ≈ 0.7) but strongly environment-dependent. Reaction norm shapes across climatic and density axes point to distinct mechanisms, including compensatory growth under benign adult conditions and density-dependent modulation of early-life differences. We further show that the conditions experienced in adulthood largely drive these patterns and determine whether early-life advantages are retained, even when explicitly tested within an environmental-matching paradigm. Decomposing the correlation using 38 generations of pedigree data revealed no evidence of gene-by-environment interactions. Instead, the observed phenotypic correlation reaction norms could be attributed almost entirely to environmentally-sensitive non-genetic individual differences. Overall, our findings show that climatic and demographic shifts can substantially reshape developmental carry-over without altering the genetic architecture tying body mass across life stages, with implications for how reliably early-life mass can predict individual quality and adult traits in wild animal populations.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.