B-96: When “Normal” Isn’t Normal: Functional Impairment Despite Average Cognitive Scores
Abstract
Objective: This case study illustrates how a seemingly normative neuropsychological performance can be associated with significant functional impairment because of high premorbid functioning. Method/Data Selection: A 41-year-old female was referred for neuropsychological evaluation following a workplace assault resulting in diagnoses of concussion and PTSD. She reported blurry vision and cognitive, emotional, and somatic symptoms, including anxiety, depression, trauma-related distress, pain, and sleep disturbance, which impacted her occupational and social functioning. A comprehensive battery was administered, which included tests of psychomotor speed, visual-spatial ability, visual and verbal memory, working memory, language, executive functioning, as well as tests of malingering and personality. Premorbid cognition was estimated to be superior given her past cognitive testing and exceptional educational history (e.g., pursuing a second doctoral degree in integrated biology). Results/Data Synthesis: Results were broadly within the average to above-average ranges across domains, indicating intact lateralized (language, visuospatial) and anterior-posterior systems (reasoning, memory). However, a significant decline from estimated premorbid functioning suggested reduced cognitive efficiency despite normative scores. Impairments were present during timed or interference conditions, consistent with reduced cognitive efficiency. Personality measures supported the dysregulation of arousal/affective systems. This pattern reflects a dissociation between “normal” cognitive functioning and reduced functional efficiency under increased cognitive demand. Conclusions: This case highlights the importance of considering relative cognitive decline and functional impairment beyond normative test scores. Neuropsychological assessment can detect meaningful changes in functioning even in the absence of a typical neurocognitive disorder diagnosis. For clinicians and trainees, integrating test data with functional and emotional context is critical for accurate case conceptualization, diagnosis, and treatment planning.