Skip to content
#small language model Review Open access

The Role of the Private Sector in the Governance of Circular Cities Initiatives: Towards a Conceptual Framework

Oct 2026 · Sustainable Development · 0 citations · 47 references
Sustainability and Climate Change Governance Urban Planning and Governance

Abstract

Despite growing policy and scholarly interest in circular cities, limited attention has been paid to how private‐sector actors shape the governance of circular urban transitions across different spatial contexts. Existing research has largely focused on circular business models, technological innovation, and municipal strategies, while overlooking questions of governance, environmental justice, and ecological valuation. While a substantial body of work examines public–private partnerships, multi‐actor governance, and urban sustainability transitions, these literatures have not been systematically integrated to examine how different types of private‐sector actors, ranging from multinational corporations to informal‐sector waste workers, exercise governance influence, encounter power asymmetries, and produce differentiated outcomes across spatial contexts. This paper addresses this gap through a PRISMA‐guided systematic literature review of 81 peer‐reviewed studies. Drawing on polycentric governance theory, institutional theory, and an environmental justice framework encompassing distributional, procedural, and recognitional dimensions, the study develops a conceptual framework for understanding private‐sector involvement in circular city governance. The review finds that private‐sector participation is shaped by structurally embedded power asymmetries that existing governance frameworks inadequately address. In advanced metropolitan regions, the reviewed studies indicate that large corporations and infrastructure providers tend to leverage their superior resources, technical expertise, and advocacy capacity to shape governance arrangements, steering circular transitions towards capital‐intensive technological solutions while marginalising community‐embedded alternatives. In developing and transitional urban contexts, small enterprises, social and solidarity economy organisations, and informal‐sector actors perform essential circular functions, handling over 50% of waste management in many cities, yet remain largely excluded from governance deliberations. The findings further highlight persistent spatial disparities in circular economy investment, limited integration of ecological valuation and natural capital accounting into governance systems, and inadequate attention to environmental justice outcomes. The paper proposes a conceptual framework comprising four interrelated dimensions: circular city context, a spatially differentiated actor ecosystem that disaggregates private‐sector actors by organisational mission and governance capacity, integrated governance mechanisms that explicitly incorporate power‐sensitive accountability structures, and multi‐scalar outcomes assessed through environmental justice criteria. Unlike existing generic governance typologies, the framework embeds power analysis and environmental justice as constitutive elements rather than peripheral concerns, thereby bridging polycentric governance, institutional theory, and critical urban political economy perspectives. To render the framework empirically applicable, the paper specifies six testable propositions describing causal relationships among its dimensions, proposes measurable indicators for each component, and illustrates how the framework can be applied in advanced, emerging, developing, and industrial‐legacy urban settings. The review is limited by its reliance on English‐language, peer‐reviewed studies drawn predominantly from European contexts, and the framework's Global South components should therefore be treated as propositions for testing rather than validated findings. The study contributes to research on urban sustainability transitions by providing a theoretically grounded foundation for comparative and longitudinal investigations of private‐sector governance and by identifying priorities for future scholarship, particularly in under‐represented Global South contexts.

Read PDF

Similar papers

#small language model Dataset Open access Oct 2026

Socratic guiding questions in synthetic arithmetic data: matched LoRA runs (revision v2)

Supporting data, adapters, predictions and code for the article *Low-Cost LoRA Fine-Tuning of Small Language Models for Multi-Step Arithmetic Reasoning* by Jake O'Grady, Asena Isik Gürhan, Chee Fong Ting and Effirul Ramlan (University of Galway). We generated 20,000 GSM8K-derived arithmetic problems with step-by-step s...

O'Grady, Jake, Gürhan, Asena Isik, Chee, Fong Ting et al. · 465 citations
#computer vision Open access Jun 2016

Software Development in Startup Companies: The Greenfield Startup Model

The results are packaged in the Greenfield Startup Model (GSM), which explains the priority of startups to release the product as quickly as possible, and the need to shorten time-to-market, by speeding up the development through low-precision engineering activities.

Carmine Giardino, Nicolò Paternoster, M. Unterkalmsteiner et al. · 178 citations · ⚡14
#computer vision Open access Oct 2016

Software Startups - A Research Agenda

Software startup companies develop innovative, software-intensive products within limited timeframes and with few resources, searching for sustainable and scalable business models.

M. Unterkalmsteiner, P. Abrahamsson, Xiaofeng Wang et al. · 157 citations · ⚡17
#machine learning Review Open access Oct 2016

“Failures” to be celebrated: an analysis of major pivots of software startups

This study conducts a case survey study based on the secondary data of the major pivots happened in 49 software startups, and demonstrates that customer need pivot is the most common among all pivot types.

Sohaib Shahid Bajwa, Xiaofeng Wang, Anh Nguyen-Duc et al. · 127 citations · ⚡15
#computer vision Review Open access May 2015

A survey study on major technical barriers affecting the decision to adopt cloud services

The comparison of adopter and non-adopter sample reveals three potential adoption inhibitor, security, data privacy, and portability, which underlines the importance of the technical and security perspectives for research investigating the adoption of technology.

Nattakarn Phaphoom, Xiaofeng Wang, S. Samuel et al. · 111 citations · ⚡8
#large language models Review Open access Nov 2020

Status of the WHO recommended timing and frequency of antenatal care visits in Northern Bangladesh

Objective There is dearth of information on the timeliness of antenatal care (ANC) uptake. This study aimed to determine the timely ANC uptake by a medically trained provider (MTP) as per the World Health Organization (WHO) recommendations and the country guideline. Methods Cross-sectional survey was done with 2,731 wo...

B. Sarker, Musfikur Rahman, T. Rahman et al. · 89 citations · ⚡7

Related blog posts

Google DeepMind Blog Nov 18, 2026

Genie 4 is now available

We are rolling out a new Project Genie experience to eligible Google AI Ultra subscribers, opening access to our new Genie 4 world model.

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.