USER-GENERATED CONTENT VERSUS TRADITIONAL DIGITAL ADVERTISING: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THEIR EFFECTIVENESS ON ENGAGEMENT AND PURCHASE BEHAVIOR ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Abstract
This article examines the comparative effectiveness of user generated content (UGC) versus traditional digital advertising on social media, focusing on its impact on two strategic digital marketing variables: engagement and purchase behavior. Given the limited evidence that directly contrasts both content types under equivalent metrics, a mixed methods study with a nonexperimental, cross sectional design was developed, based on content analysis of posts published on Instagram and TikTok by beauty and consumer brands (Maybelline New York, Pantene, and Secret). An analysis matrix was built to register quantitative variables (likes, comments, shares, and views) and qualitative variables (narrative style, format, and perceived authenticity) across a sample evenly distributed between both content types. Results show that UGC generates predominantly qualitative engagement, expressed through extensive comments, statements of preference, and explicit purchase intent, whereas traditional advertising produces more quantitative and superficial interaction, concentrated in quick reactions. Engagement is also found to act as a bridge between content type and purchase behavior, and the effectiveness of each format largely depends on each brand particular digital strategy. The study concludes that UGC and traditional advertising are not mutually exclusive strategies but complementary ones, and offers practical implications for content planning in digital environments.