Comparative Efficacy and Safety of Needling-Based Therapies Versus Ablative Fractional Lasers for Scar Management: A Systematic Review and an Exploratory Meta-Analysis.
Needling-based therapies and ablative fractional lasers are widely used for scar management, but their efficacy and safety remain uncertain. In this systematic review, we aimed to assess the safety and efficacy of both needling-based therapy and ablative fractional laser therapy.
Methods
This review followed PRISMA 2020 and the Cochrane Handbook. PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and Cochrane were searched from inception to 9 April 2026 without restrictions. Studies enrolling patients with scars of any etiology and comparing a needling-based therapy with an ablative fractional laser were included. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs), non-randomized trials, and cohort studies were eligible. Risk of bias was assessed using RoB 2, ROBINS-I, and the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. Because of heterogeneity, findings were synthesized narratively, with exploratory random-effects meta-analysis where data were sufficiently comparable.
Results
Twenty-seven studies involving 1137 participants were included, comprising 17 RCTs, 2 non-randomized comparative trials, and 8 cohort studies. Most studies evaluated atrophic or hypertrophic acne scars (18 studies; 870 patients), while fewer studies assessed striae (4 studies; 87 patients), burn or postburn scars (3 studies; 105 patients), and traumatic scars (2 studies; 75 patients). Both treatment categories improved scar appearance. In many comparisons of atrophic acne scars, ablative fractional lasers, particularly fractional CO2 and, in some studies, Er:YAG systems, suggested greater improvement than microneedling. However, needling-based therapies were associated with shorter downtime, better tolerability, and fewer pigmentary adverse effects. Microneedling radiofrequency appeared to provide efficacy closer to that of ablative lasers in several individual studies and demonstrated a more favorable safety profile. Recent combination regimens appeared promising.
Conclusion
Available evidence suggests that both modalities can improve scars. Ablative fractional lasers may offer greater efficacy, whereas needling-based therapies may provide better tolerability and pigment safety. These conclusions should be interpreted cautiously because of clinical heterogeneity and the sensitivity of the exploratory pooled estimate to individual studies. Treatment selection should remain individualized according to scar type, patient priorities, and acceptable downtime.
TRIAL REGISTRATION
The protocol was registered in PROSPERO (CRD420261383840).
Comparing the clinical response, safety, and recovery profiles of fractional CO₂ and erbium-based fractional lasers for atrophic acne scars suggests a favorable clinical-response signal for fractional CO₂ laser, accompanied by greater procedural pain and longer recovery.
Xin Song, Bing-Wei Zhi· Lasers in Medical Science· 0 citations
Current comparative evidence suggests that MNRF-based interventions can improve facial atrophic acne scars and may offer tolerability advantages in selected patients, however, the available evidence does not establish uniform efficacy superiority of MNRF over all fractional laser modalities.
Introduction Infantile hemangiomas (IH) are the most common childhood vascular tumors, potentially complicated by ulceration and permanent functional or aesthetic sequelae. Current treatments include corticosteroids, β-blockers, and lasers, among others, existing evidence relies predominantly on direct pairwise compari...
Ming-Xuan Kong, Shi-Jie Zhang, Dan Ren et al.· Frontiers in Pharmacology· 0 citations
Background/Objectives: To systematically evaluate and compare the clinical efficacy and safety of non-cryotherapy modalities versus standard liquid nitrogen cryotherapy for the treatment of plantar warts, while exploring the influence of specific cryotherapy procedural parameters and intervention-related subgroup chara...
Aliyah Abdulmohsen Alabdulqader, Suliman Alkhudairy, Abdulelah Saeed Mohammed Alwahabi et al.· Journal of Clinical Medicine· 0 citations
Scarring caused by trauma, burns, surgery, and other dermal fibrotic conditions can lead to functional limitation and cosmetic distress. The comparative effectiveness of fractional laser therapy and microneedling for non-acne scars remains uncertain. We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized cont...
Dong Dong, Yun Hong, Jia Wang et al.· Lasers in Medical Science· 0 citations
Objective: To synthesize clinical outcomes and safety of surgical and advanced interventional treatments for pediatric refractory constipation using a phenotype-directed, domain-specific approach.
Methods: This systematic review with domain-specific meta-analyses of proportions followed PRISMA 2020 and was prospective...
Freddy Alexander Aldaz Vallejo, J. Oliveros-Rivero, C. C. Patiño González· Turkish archives of pediatri...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.