Skip to content
Review Open access

When AI Delegation Becomes Dependence: Administrative Judgment at Risk

Oct 2026 · AI & Future Society · Vol 2, pp. 1-18 · 0 citations · 22 references

TL;DR

A theory of institutional AI dependence as a task–role–workflow configuration combining substantial delegation of core cognition with insufficient task-required review or recovery capacity is developed.

Abstract

Public organizations can delegate cognitive work to artificial intelligence while losing the capacity to scrutinize or resume that work. When does useful delegation become institutional dependence? This article develops a theory of institutional AI dependence as a task–role–workflow configuration combining substantial delegation of core cognition with insufficient task-required review or recovery capacity. It distinguishes two vulnerabilities: inadequate challenge during AI-supported work and inadequate capacity to continue judgment-intensive work when the system is unavailable. Extensive delegation with adequate distributed expertise and tested recovery constitutes managed delegation. Integrating cognitive offloading, automation, organizational learning, and public-administration research, the article extends Song et al.’s (2026) account of epistemic authority to organizational workflows and distinguishes perceived credibility from procedural authority embedded in defaults and override rules. Seven propositions connect practice displacement, challenge behavior, knowledge retention, subsequent delegation, and responsibility–control alignment. They specify how task-relevant practice, diagnostic feedback, and transferable knowledge shape retained capacity over time. The contribution is a task-relative diagnosis of threatened administrative judgment and a set of testable formation mechanisms. The framework guides public organizations in governing current agentic systems and preparing review and recovery arrangements for more capable AI.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Oct 2026

From Copilots to Coworkers: How Autonomous AI Agents Reshape Organizational Roles and Decision Authority: A Structured Integrative Review and Research Agenda

Autonomous artificial intelligence agents extend generative AI from producing content on demand to pursuing goals through planning, memory, tool use, environmental feedback, and iterative action. This shift matters organizationally because agency is no longer confined to recommendation: systems can increasingly initiat...

Miguel Rozalez · 0 citations
Review Open access 2026

Human-Artificial Intelligence Collaboration in Strategic Decision-Making: A Systematic Literature Review

This systematic literature review critically examines AI delegation, where analytical or decision tasks are transferred to AI, and AI augmentation and proposes a contingent collaboration framework in which decision quality depends on matching AI engagement mode to task characteristics, human expertise, and governance c...

Margret Yusuf Malgwi, Zakari Mohammed, Caleb Markus · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Accountability arbitrage: ethical tensions in AI agent accountability infrastructure

It is predicted that expected record advantage will increase agent selection near evidence thresholds, while anticipated exposure will reduce recorded deployment in high-discretion tasks, and governance implications include human–AI evidentiary parity, substantive-performance floors, review authority, and proportionate...

A. Li · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Sep 2026

When Should a Human Take Back Control? Optimal Delegation under Turbulent AI Risk

Deploying AI systems requires deciding when to delegate tasks and when humans should intervene to monitor and mitigate risk induced by AI operations. These decisions are challenging when failures cluster: a hallucination or harmful output can trigger further errors, creating periods of elevated risk. We introduce a con...

Hao Yan, Julien Roze, V. Upadhyay et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.