Skip to content
Review Open access

Measuring impacts of integrated prevention services: rapid evidence review and qualitative analysis

Oct 2026 · European Journal of Public Health · Vol 36 · 0 citations

TL;DR

A one-size-fits-all approach may not be suitable to measure preventative impact across a range of services focused on different outcomes and needs and co-production is needed to define what success looks like in terms of prevention for different services, interventions and stakeholders.

Abstract

Abstract Background The complex challenges facing health and social care in Wales directed the Welsh Government to establish an Integrated Community Care System (ICCS). The ICCS involves a shift towards integrated and preventative care approaches, but measuring the impact of such approaches is challenging due to a lack of robust measurement tools and frameworks. Methods A rapid evidence review of existing measurement frameworks and tools for assessing the preventative impact of integrated care was conducted; early findings were sense-checked against current practice with national and international stakeholders. Social Sciences Citation Index; MEDLINE; CINAHL were searched from 2000 to October 2025, plus a large range of organisational websites. 3 reviewers used Rayyan software to screen against inclusion criteria, data were extracted into an Excel spreadsheet for narrative synthesis. Online focus groups with stakeholders were analysed using framework analysis. Results 4671 records were screened; 36 included in the rapid review; 13 reported on the development of measures and 33 reported on 62 measures themselves. 14 participants from policy, practice and academia, were interviewed online. While there is a wide range of tools and frameworks available, a one-size-fits-all approach may not be suitable to measure preventative impact across a range of services focused on different outcomes and needs. Focus group participants emphasised the importance of co-production to define what successful prevention looks like for each service or intervention. Identifying mechanisms and linked proxy outcomes by which preventative outcomes could be reached was important. Burden on staff and services needs to be carefully considered when implementing a new tool. Conclusions The review emphasised the importance of co-production to define ‘success’ for each service, before selecting suitable outcome measures. Key messages • A one-size-fits-all approach may not be suitable to measure preventative impact across a range of services focused on different outcomes and needs. • Co-production is needed to define what success looks like in terms of prevention for different services, interventions and stakeholders.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Measuring What Matters: Understanding Wellbeing and Prevention through Integrated Data

Background: The evidence underpinning integrated care remains uncertain, with numerous examples of evaluations finding little robust evidence of intended impacts on health or reporting conflicting results. Reasons for this include problems with the design and implementation of integrated care initiatives and issues wit...

M. Richardson · 0 citations
Review Sep 2026

Blind Spots in Safety: A Qualitative Document Review of Incident Analysis Frameworks-Implications and Practice Recommendations.

Although incident analysis frameworks guide the investigation of safety events and foster organizational learning, few studies have evaluated the extent to which they incorporate social factors [Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging (DEIB)] and Just Culture principles. A qualitative document analysis was used to...

L. B. Chiotu · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Formative assessment of best practices in primary care: early CIRCE-JA findings

Formative assessment demonstrates early progress in BP implementation across heterogeneous PHC settings while identifying key implementation barriers and facilitators that support adaptive implementation and inform subsequent evaluation of effectiveness and impact.

C. Lionis, V. Bempi, M. Vafeiadi et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Where are the Public in Prevention Science? A Scoping Review of Public Involvement in the Development and Evaluation of Family-Based Prevention Interventions.

Public involvement (PI) - research conducted with or by members of the public - is increasingly recognised as essential to high-quality intervention research. However, its role in Prevention Science, including within family-based interventions, remains unclear. We conducted a scoping review following Arksey and O'Malle...

A. Kaur, Layan Amouri, I. Koning et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Implementation barriers in Singapore’s community-based falls prevention programmes: a root cause analysis

Investigating systemic barriers to delivering FPPs in Singapore reveals three systemic gaps: an information gap obscuring need, a resource/capacity gap crippling delivery, and an economic gap making programmes unsustainable.

Catherine Wen Huey Lim, V. Koh, Jing-Wen Goh et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access 2026

Strategies to promote men's health-seeking behaviour: a systematic review

Background : Men’s underutilisation of healthcare services remains a public health challenge, contributing to delayed diagnosis, low uptake of preventive services, avoidable complications, and poor health outcomes. Although barriers to men’s health-seeking behaviour have been widely documented, less attention has been...

Lazarros Chavalala, T. Lebese, L. Makhado · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.