Comparative evaluation of siem platforms in detecting mitre att&ck techniques based on false positive analysis
Abstract
Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) platforms are essential for centralized security monitoring in Security Operations Centers (SOCs), yet they continue to face a persistent challenge: high volumes of false positive alerts that impair analyst efficiency and delay incident response. This paper presents a comparative evaluation of three SIEM platforms-Wazuh, IBM QRadar, and Splunk Enterprise Security-in detecting selected MITRE ATT&CK techniques. Several attack scenarios, including brute force authentication, network reconnaissance, and malicious command execution, were executed to assess detection accuracy, latency, false positive rates, and alert precision. Results reveal notable differences between open-source and commercial solutions. Enterprise platforms demonstrated superior correlation capabilities and lower false positive rates, while open-source Wazuh offered competitive detection performance at significantly reduced deployment costs. These findings provide practical insights into SIEM performance when detecting adversary behaviors mapped to the MITRE ATT&CK framework, offering guidance for organizations balancing cost, accuracy, and operational efficiency in their security stack selection.