Skip to content
Open access

Renegotiating autonomy and safety: disentangling tensions emerging for older adults living with smart monitoring systems

Oct 2026 · npj Health Systems · Vol 3 · 0 citations · 64 references
Medicine

TL;DR

Empirical insights into unintended consequences and a conceptual model explaining how value tensions emerge are provided, with implications for practitioners and caregivers are provided.

Abstract

Smart monitoring systems (SMS) are increasingly deployed in community-based care to empower older adults to live safely and independently. However, existing research largely treats monitoring as a process in which continuous data collection and real-time alerts are intended to translate into improved outcomes. What remains underexplored is how older adults experience monitoring and how it shapes their behavior over time. In this qualitative longitudinal study, 21 older adults are accompanied from SMS installation for more than one year, with individual semi-structured interviews conducted across four data collection phases. Findings reveal that older adults actively anticipate how the system interprets their behavior, producing three responses: reactance, that is, disengaging from devices to reclaim autonomy over safety; preemptive behavior, for instance, restructuring daily routines to avoid triggering alerts constraining their autonomy and safety; and performative compliance, that is, managing behavior to satisfy caregivers rather than personal needs, leading to a loss of autonomy. These constitute autonomy-safety value tensions: a technology designed to advance both values instead produces conditions under which protecting one systematically undermines the other. To this end, this study provides empirical insights into unintended consequences and a conceptual model explaining how value tensions emerge, with implications for practitioners and caregivers.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Negotiating Autonomy, Control, and Privacy in Always-On Home IoT Technology-Mediated Care Relationships with Older Adults

Always-on home IoT technologies, such as smart speakers, sensors, and cameras, are increasingly marketed toward older adults aging in place and their support networks for use in care contexts. At the same time, their integration into care relationships surfaces tensions around autonomy, consent, and relational power th...

Sheng-Zhi Wang, Neilly H. Tan, Sean A Munson · 1 citation
Review Open access Sep 2026

Worried, deterred, and still interested: Psychological barriers and older adults’ intentions to adopt smart home technologies

Smart home technologies (SHTs) hold promise for supporting aging in place, yet older adults’ technology adoption involves more than a straightforward response to perceived benefits. This study examined how privacy concerns and fear of dependency, along with other technology acceptance factors, are associated with...

Joonhyeog Park, Jin-Bo Niu, Tamara J. Cadet · 0 citations
Book Open access Oct 2026

Participatory Evidencing and Relational Autonomy: Co-Informing Design for Bipolar Disorder Self-Management Tools

This research developed a three-phase design-led qualitative inquiry including seafaring metaphor-based exploration, experiential tracking, and guided design exercises to investigate the needs, preferences, and self-expertise of three people diagnosed with bipolar disorder in the Netherlands and Belgium.

Karin Bogdanova, Nazli Cila, O. Kudina et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Envisioning Future Technologies for Ageing-in-Place: A Participatory Design Fiction Workshop

Background: Worldwide, populations are ageing. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that the proportion of people aged 60 years and older will increase from 12% in 2015 to 22% in 2050. As the share of older adults grows, demand for health care will rise, even though current healthcare systems are already under...

Eda Karaosmanoglu, Karlijn E. Te Boekhorst · 0 citations
Book Open access Oct 2026

Navigating New Disability as a Sociotechnical Process

Adults experiencing new disabilities must often decipher symptoms, seek diagnosis, develop treatment plans with clinicians, and build everyday adaptations, all within constrained healthcare systems. This paper examines how recently disabled adults in the United States navigate this process and use technology, and other...

Wen-Han Xue, Kelly Ramos Pereira, Taniyah Hicks et al. · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Oct 2026

Making Smart Homes Fit for Autistic Children: Family Work and Monitored Independence

General-purpose smart-home technologies are increasingly present in family life, yet how they support or disrupt autistic children and families with autistic children remains underexamined. We conducted a multi-source qualitative study drawing on five caregiver interviews, Xiaohongshu (also known internationally as Red...

Ting-Ting Xiang, Wei-Han Jiang, Hrishitva Patel et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.