First hyperpolarizability of dithienylethene-based photoswitches: a structure–property relationship study
Abstract
Despite their considerable technological potential, structure–property relationships in intramolecular charge-transfer-based photoswitches remain poorly established. Here, we present a quantum-chemical investigation of the first hyperpolarizability (β) of a family of dithienylethene (DTE)-based photoswitches, considering static, electro-optic Pockels, and second-harmonic-generation (SHG) responses. Eight donor (D)/acceptor (A) architectures, with and without alkyne (y) π-extension, are investigated in their open- and closed-ring forms using density functional theory [CAM-B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p)/GD3BJ/(PCM)] in the gas phase and three continuum solvents, with dynamic responses evaluated at 1064 nm. Ring closure generally enhances total first hyperpolarizability (βtot) by restoring through core conjugation, while donor–acceptor asymmetry emerges as the dominant structural factor governing large NLO responses. Alkyne extension further enhances the response when coupled with a push–pull architecture. Solvation modulates both the magnitude and direction of the response, producing pronounced amplification of the closed/open βtot ratio in selected systems and a striking reorientation of the SHG response vector for Dy–yAopen. Time-dependent DFT analysis suggests that the reorientation is associated with a redistribution among nearby excited-state contribution. Importantly, βtot and the directional alignment ratio η are not necessarily correlated. We therefore introduce RNLO as a combined comparative descriptor that captures both response magnitude and directionality. RNLO identifies the closed push–pull architectures, particularly Dy–yAclosed, D–yAclosed, and Dy–Aclosed, as the most favorable systems among the considered chromophores. Overall, the results show that NLO performance is governed by the coupled effects of donor–acceptor asymmetry, ring closure, π-extension, and dielectric environment, and that optimization of both response magnitude and directionality is essential for establishing meaningful structure–property relationships in DTE photoswitches.