Skip to content
Open access

Clinical staging in eating disorders: qualitative insights from those with lived experience, carers, and clinicians

Sep 2026 · Journal of Eating Disorders · 0 citations

TL;DR

Novel insights are demonstrated in the value of stakeholder input in informing the development and refinement of clinical staging models for EDs that can accommodate individual differences, non-linear illness trajectories, and stage‑modifying factors.

Abstract

Clinical staging offers a framework for understanding and treating psychiatric disorders along a continuum and across dimensions, yet its application to eating disorders (EDs) remains limited. This study aimed to qualitatively explore clinical staging and stage modifiers in EDs across those with lived experience, carers, and clinicians. Under a critical realist ontological stance, semi-structured interviews and focus groups were conducted with 21 participants (10 with lived ED experience, 2 carers, 9 clinicians). Data were analysed using Fryer’s critical realist approach to thematic analysis. Themes were developed as nuanced causal explanations of participants’ accounts of illness development, progression, treatment experiences, and recovery. Five superordinate themes were identified: (1) Clinical staging: seeking structure in a fluid illness (2) How eating disorders take hold, and hold on, (3) The wider forces shaping illness trajectories, (4) Healthcare experiences influence illness progression, and (5) Recovery: building life beyond the ED. Staging could largely be interpreted as an accurate framework for conceptualising EDs. However, EDs were consistently described as following a non-linear trajectory and concerns were raised on whether stages would be interpreted rigidly. Early intervention was considered crucial to prevent illness progression, but several barriers to early ED treatment were identified. Harmful treatment experiences were seen as shaping illness progression and stages. The results suggest a preference for staging approaches that are flexible and person‑centred, and that can accommodate individual differences, non‑linear illness trajectories, and stage‑modifying factors. These novel insights demonstrate the value of stakeholder input in informing the development and refinement of clinical staging models for EDs.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Oct 2026

Exploring eating disorder voices: a qualitative study of individuals in recovery - Hearing ED's voice.

The eating disorder voice (EDV) has been increasingly recognised as implicated in the development and maintenance of eating disorders (EDs). However, research has predominantly examined anorexia nervosa (AN), limiting understanding across other diagnoses. This study aimed to investigate the lived experiences of the EDV...

Kim-Marie Crown, Kieron Oakland · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

A qualitative description of the daily living functioning of people diagnosed with borderline personality disorder from consumer, carer and clinician perspectives

Abstract Introduction Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is a severe and prevalent mental illness. Longitudinal research consistently demonstrates that people diagnosed with BPD experience persistent functional impairment despite current psychotherapeutic treatment. Functional impairment is typically defined in term...

Dillon Tepper, Ben Sellar, S. Shipley et al. · 1 citation
Open access Sep 2026

Exploring the psychosocial impact of receiving and coping with a chronic illness diagnosis amongst young adults

The psychosocial impact of chronic illnesses (CIs) is well-documented; however, existing literature predominantly centers on older adults, often overlooking young adults navigating a critical period of identity formation and developmental milestones. Receiving a chronic illness diagnosis during this stage functio...

Jonathan David Ramdawar · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Making recovery conceivable: perspectives from healthcare professionals using psychologically and behaviourally informed approaches to chronic fatigue syndrome

Abstract Purpose Healthcare professionals (HCPs) treating patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) work within a contested field marked by uncertainty. This study explored how HCPs using psychologically and behaviourally informed approaches to CFS understood therapeutic change and their role in facilitating recover...

Anne Karen Bakken, A. Mengshoel, O. Synnes · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

It's All in Your Head: A Qualitative Examination of the Help-Seeking Experiences of Women Suffering Postpartum Psychosis.

It is emphasised that enhancing outcomes for women affected by postpartum psychosis requires increased focus within both research and clinical domains, ensuring that maternal distress is accurately identified, comprehended and validated.

Donna McMahon, Tess Rutherford, Reilly Smout et al. · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Longitudinal trajectories of treatment response in patients with longstanding eating disorders

It is demonstrated that adults with L-ED show diverse trajectories of change and can experience meaningful improvement in response to MED-DBT, challenging assumptions that individuals with a L-ED are treatment-resistant and underscore the importance of continuing to deliver treatments that promote change.

Eva-Molly Petitto Dunbar, Susan Murray, S. Abber et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.