Skip to content
Open access

A quality appraisal of clinical practice guidelines for herpes zoster and postherpetic neuralgia using the AGREE II instrument

Oct 2026 · Medicine · Vol 105 · 0 citations · 32 references
Medicine

TL;DR

The findings reveal considerable variability in quality, with overall low-to-moderate quality observed in the guidelines for HZ and PHN, and highlight the need to address the domains with consistently low scores identified by the AGREE II instrument by adopting a multidisciplinary approach, strengthening applicability, and ensuring rigor in the development process to improve guideline quality.

Abstract

Background: This study systematically assesses the methodological quality of both Western and traditional medicine clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for herpes zoster (HZ) and postherpetic neuralgia (PHN) using the Appraisal of Guidelines Research and Evaluation (AGREE II) instrument. Methods: A systematic search was conducted up to January 10, 2025 to identify CPGs for HZ or PHN, regardless of whether they were based on Western or traditional medicine. All CPGs addressing diagnosis, evaluation, treatment, prevention, and management were included. Two evaluators independently screened the records and extracted the data. The quality of the CPGs was independently assessed by 5 evaluators using the AGREE II instrument. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was calculated to assess inter-rater reliability. Results: Eleven CPGs were included, consisting of ten from Western medicine and 1 from traditional medicine. The AGREE II domain scores were as follows: The “Clarity of Presentation” domain received the highest score (76.2%), whereas “Editorial Independence,” “Stakeholder Involvement,” and “Applicability” scored below 30%, with “Applicability” receiving the lowest score (10.9%). Inter-rater reliability was excellent, with ICCs for the AGREE II domains ranging from 0.927 to 0.990. Four CPGs were rated as Moderate quality (Recommended with modifications), and 6 CPGs were of Low quality (Not recommended). Among the Western medicine CPGs, JASP 2021 was the only 1 rated as High quality (Recommended), whereas CACMS 2013, the only traditional medicine CPG, was rated as Low quality (Not recommended). Conclusion: The findings reveal considerable variability in quality, with overall low-to-moderate quality observed in the guidelines for HZ and PHN. These results highlight the need to address the domains with consistently low scores identified by the AGREE II instrument by adopting a multidisciplinary approach, strengthening applicability, and ensuring rigor in the development process to improve guideline quality.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access Sep 2026

Determinants of Herpes Zoster Vaccine Hesitancy: An Updated Systematic Review Based on the 5C Model

Background/Objectives: Herpes zoster (HZ) represents a substantial public health burden, particularly among older adults and individuals at increased risk of severe disease. Despite effective vaccines, uptake remains suboptimal. This systematic review aimed to update evidence on HZ vaccination willingness, acceptance,...

M. Chiavarini, A. Genga, G. M. Ricciotti et al. · 0 citations
Review Nov 2026

Recurrence Rate of Genital Warts Between Treatment With Imiquimod and Polyphenon E: A Systematic Review.

OBJECTIVES Genital warts, a frequent manifestation of human papillomavirus, are commonly treated with Imiquimod 5% or Polyphenon E (10% or 15%), which differ in recurrence rates. This systematic review aimed to investigate the recurrence rates of genital warts following treatment with these agents. METHODS This study...

Fatemeh Rashidi, H. Riazi, M. Simbar et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Evaluation of the efficacy of cannabinoids in the control of chronic pain in patients with fibromyalgia: a meta-analytic review

Background: Fibromyalgia (FM) is a neurosensory disorder characterized by chronic musculoskeletal pain, fatigue, and sleep disturbances. Its treatment remains challenging, and conventional therapies are not always effective, which has encouraged the search for alternative therapeutic approaches. Objective: To compare t...

Thiago César da Cunha Fontes, Victor Augusto de Alencar Menezes, T. L. de Melo e Silva et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Contemporary consensus and emerging directions in premature and delayed ejaculation: recommendations from the 5th International Consultation on Sexual Medicine.

INTRODUCTION Disorders of ejaculation, including premature ejaculation (PE) and delayed ejaculation (DE), are common conditions with a substantial impact on men's quality of life and their relationships. This review synthesizes the latest findings on their etiology, epidemiology, evaluation, and management. This study...

E. Şerefoğlu, Alan W. Shindel, Yan Zhang et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Quality of osteoporosis management guidelines produced in China: a systematic review

The methodological and recommendation quality of Chinese osteoporosis CPGs is moderate, and recommendations focusing on functional assessment, diet and exercise, rehabilitation, and environmental modifications are valuable.

Xiao-Nan Liu, Meng-Ya Ge, Caie Wu et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Development and validation of an evidence-based otorhinolaryngological care protocol for patients with achondroplasia: a pilot study

Highlights • Evidence-based ENT protocol for achondroplasia.• Evidence-based otorhinolaryngological manifestations in patients with achondroplasia.• Content validation by expert panel (pediatrician, geneticist, and otolaryngologist).• The protocol was applied in a clinical setting, confirming its clinical feasibility.•...

Cynthia Moreno, M. Galera · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.