Skip to content
Open access

Environmental DNA sampling workflow matters: testing different approaches on marine microbial assemblages in three coastal areas of Greece

Sep 2026 · Frontiers in Microbiology · Vol 17 · 0 citations · 75 references
Medicine

Abstract

Introduction Environmental DNA (eDNA) and high-throughput sequencing are now common tools for investigating marine microbial communities in coastal environments. Nevertheless, different eDNA sampling workflows are used across studies, while direct comparisons of their outputs under the same environmental and analytical framework remain limited. Methods We aimed to compare three eDNA sampling approaches, two active filtration workflows using membrane filtration (Filter) and Sterivex cartridges (Sterivex), and one passive Gauze-based workflow, applied simultaneously in three coastal gulfs of Greece, to examine whether sampling workflow influences the recovered bacterial and eukaryotic diversity and community structure via 16S and 18S rRNA gene metabarcoding. The workflows differed in sampling characteristics, including pre-screening, processed water volume and capture mechanism, with 200-5m pre-screening applied only to Filter and Sterivex. Results Filter and Sterivex produced concordant patterns of community structure and generally lower between-sample variability. They were nonetheless not fully equivalent: differences in diversity, taxonomic representation and network hub identity indicate that the two active workflows recover partially distinct community representations. Gauze produced a more variable and compositionally distinct signal, particularly for eukaryotic communities, where concordance with the active workflows was weak and occasional low-yield recovery occurred. Workflow-related differences were also observed in exploratory co-occurrence network topology and hub identity, indicating that workflow choice can influence downstream ecological interpretation. Discussion Each workflow appeared to be suitable for different research objectives, with passive sampling providing complementary information. Maintaining a consistent sampling workflow is therefore particularly important for monitoring programs and cross-study comparisons.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Conference Open access Oct 2026

Hidden pitfalls in aquatic eDNA sampling: A passive eDNA sampler reveals method-dependent biodiversity inference in freshwater systems

Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding has become a powerful tool for freshwater biodiversity assessment, yet the physical architecture of eDNA samplers remains an underexamined source of methodological bias. Filtration is routinely treated as a neutral preparatory step; however, filter material, pore geometry, matrix...

Fong Yang · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Integrating active and passive environmental DNA sampling into coral reef assessments: implications for community-based biomonitoring in Hawaiʻi

Environmental DNA (eDNA) has transformed biodiversity monitoring, but its application for long-term ecological assessment remains limited by uncertainty in the temporal stability and consistency of eDNA signals, as well as by workflows that require specialized equipment and analytical support. Broader use of eDNA in co...

Cécile M. Vimond, Zoe Hill, Cameron A. J. Walsh et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

A Snap-Shot Metabarcoding Survey of Fungal Diversity at the Intersection of the Atmosphere and the Danube River

Fungi represent one of the most diverse groups of organisms and inhabit multiple environmental compartments, including the atmosphere, where they occur as highly mobile biological particles. The atmosphere is increasingly recognized as an active ecological compartment integrating signals from terrestrial and aquatic ec...

Ljiljana Janjušević, B. Šikoparija, Milomir Stefanović et al. · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Combination of high throughput sequencing and morphological identification assess the diversity and distribution of key benthic taxa in anthropogenic environments

Port environments are both heavily impacted by human activities and of high societal importance, making their ecological monitoring essential. The assessment of marine macro invertebrate communities is an important part of such monitoring programs. In an era where molecular methods, such as metabarcoding of bulk DNA or...

M. Grosse, T. Bakken, Arne Nygren et al. · 0 citations
Review 2026

Environmental DNA Metabarcoding for Marine Biodiversity Monitoring: Species Detection Concordance With Traditional Trawl Surveys Across 24 Temperate and Tropical Sites

This study investigates concordance between eDNA metabarcoding species detection and traditional bottom trawl survey catch across 24 temperate and tropical marine sites spanning five ocean regions within the context of marine biology and environmental genomics, an area of growing scientific importance given its implica...

Sian M. Roberts, Kofi T. Mensah-Baffour, Aiko Y. Nakamura · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.