Skip to content

Cariogram-Based Dental Caries Risk Assessment: A Cross-Sectional Statistical Validation of Sector Values Against Caries Severity, Plaque Index, and ICDAS Score

Sep 2026 · Natural Resources for Human Health · Vol 6, pp. 1525-1532 · 0 citations · 5 references

TL;DR

Ciogram sector values, particularly the dark blue (dietary) and red (bacterial susceptibility) sectors, were strongly and independently associated with caries severity in this sample, supporting the Cariogram's value as a risk-stratification instrument.

Abstract

Objectives: This study aimed to (1) compare Cariogram sector values between low-risk and very-high-risk individuals, (2) assess the association of plaque index and ICDAS score with caries severity, (3) evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of individual Cariogram sectors in distinguishing carious from non-carious subjects, and (4) identify predictors of caries severity through ordinal logistic regression.Materials and Methods: Across-sectional sample of 512 subjects was analyzed — 256 with active caries (stratified as Mild, n=96; Moderate, n=60; Severe, n=100) and 256 caries-free controls. Non-parametric tests (Mann-Whitney U; Kruskal-Wallis with D wass-Steel-Critchlow-Fligner post hoccomparisons) were used given non-normal data distributions. Chi-square tests examined associations between categorical clinical variables and severity. Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) analysis with Youden's Index determined optimal cut-off values, and ordinal logistic regression identified independent predictors of severity.Results: All five Cariogram sectors differed significantly between low-risk and very-high-risk groups (all p < .001). Each sector achieved complete separation between the caries and non-caries groups in ROC analysis (AUC = 1.00). Ordinal logistic regression showed that higher darkbluesectorvalues(OR=0.325,95%CI:0.256–0.400)andredsectorvalues(OR=0.117, 95%CI:0.065–0.189)were independently associated with reduced odds of severe caries(both p<.001), while the blue sector approached but did not reach significance(OR=1.123,p=.062). The model explained 76.6% of variance in severity (McFadden's R² = 0.766). Plaque Index and ICDAS score were both significantly associated with caries severity (χ² = 28.647 and 8.927, respectively; p < .05).Conclusions: Cariogram sector values, particularly the dark blue (dietary) and red (bacterial susceptibility) sectors, were strongly and independently associated with caries severity in this sample, supporting the Cariogram's value as a risk-stratification instrument. Because the caries and non-caries groups in this analysis represented extremes of risk rather than a continuous clinical population, the perfect diagnostic separation observed should be interpreted as internal validation rather than a general is able estimate of real-world diagnostic accuracy.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Distinct patterns of caries, erosive tooth wear, and hypomineralization in preschool children: a population-based study of associated factors

To assess prevalence, severity, and co-occurrence of dental caries, erosive tooth wear (ETW), and hypomineralization in preschool children, and to analyse their associations with general health, developmental, and sociodemographic factors. This cross-sectional study was conducted within the mandatory school entry exami...

J. Biermann, Angelika Puls, Trixie Heller et al. · 0 citations
#explainable ai Review Open access Oct 2026

Machine Learning for Predicting Dental Caries Presence and Severity: An Age-Cohort Perspective from a Nationally Representative Survey in Brazil

Abstract Introduction Although preventable, dental caries remains a global public health challenge due to its multifactorial nature and the deep influence of socio-structural determinants. This study evaluates the performance of artificial intelligence (AI) models as decision-support frameworks for population-level ris...

Jessye Melgarejo Do Amaral Giordani, Orlando Luiz Do Amaral, Maria Laura Braccini Fagundes et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Caries Diagnosis and Management by Dentists and Dental Hygienists: A Pilot Study.

BACKGROUND Dutch dental hygienists are trained to indicate, take, and interpret intraoral radiographs to diagnose and treat primary caries. Therefore, the aim of this pilot study was to explore whether the profession (dentists or dental hygienists) influences caries detection based on intraoral radiographs and the subs...

M. Bozia, E. Berkhout, D. Slot et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.