Skip to content
Review Open access

The Case for Cases: From Compelling Stories to Responsible Reasoning and Adaptive Learning

Oct 2026 · International Journal of Human Research and Social Science Studies · 0 citations

Abstract

Examples, stories, and cases connect abstract propositions with situations, yet their pedagogical usefulness does not establish their evidentiary adequacy. This conceptual article examines how case-based learning can support understanding, responsible judgment, and adaptive knowledge use without allowing memorable narratives to substitute for warranted inference. Building on an originating essay about the value of examples, the analysis integrates selected scholarship on case-based reasoning, worked examples, analogical comparison, narrative persuasion, epistemic cognition, and Cognitive Flexibility Theory. The methodology consists of purposive literature selection, conceptual differentiation, comparison of explanatory mechanisms, examination of boundary conditions, and development of an integrative instructional framework; it is neither a systematic review nor an empirical intervention study. The conceptual results distinguish five functions of cases: illustration, epistemic testing, engagement, relational comparison, and adaptive reconstruction. They also identify six connected design requirements: specifying instructional purpose, establishing provenance, selecting meaningful contrasts, scaffolding interpretation, assessing transfer, and recalibrating claims. Four propositions specify testable relationships among case diversity, comparative activity, evidentiary transparency, prior knowledge, and transfer performance. The discussion addresses the tension between simplifying instruction and preserving contextual complexity, the ethical consequences of narrative selection, and the evaluation of digital case libraries. The article argues that instructional value depends less on accumulating compelling stories than on coordinating the purposes, evidence, comparisons, and assessments through which learners encounter them. Its contribution is an alignment between learning from cases and reasoning responsibly about what cases establish, together with a research agenda for evaluating that alignment across educational and professional settings through future empirical inquiry.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.