B-195: Validity Testing in Pediatric Intellectual Disability
Abstract
Objective: This review examined the empirical utility of stand-alone performance validity tests (PVTs), symptom validity tests, and embedded validity indicators in pediatric intellectual disability assessment, with emphasis on their neuropsychological and forensic relevance. Method/Data Selection: A systematic review of peer-reviewed empirical studies published between 2002 and 2023 was conducted using PsycINFO and PubMed. Search terms included intellectual disability, pediatric neuropsychology, performance validity, symptom validity, embedded indicators, and malingering. Inclusion criteria required pediatric samples or populations directly relevant to the assessment of intellectual disability. Seventeen studies met criteria, representing 4,129 participants across clinical, simulation, developmental disability, and forensic samples. Results/Data Synthesis: Stand-alone, recognition-based performance validity tests (PVTs; e.g., Test of Memory Malingering, Word Memory Test, Medical Symptom Validity Test) consistently demonstrated stronger specificity, interpretive clarity, and clinical utility than embedded validity indicators. Across studies, children and adolescents with intellectual disability generally performed within valid ranges when exerting adequate effort, indicating that intellectual disability alone does not account for PVT failure. In contrast, embedded indicators, including Digit Span performance, recognition discriminability indices, number correct/longest span on visual working memory tasks, and atypical failure (failure on easier tasks compared to more difficult tasks) showed greater variability and increased risk of false positive misclassification. This likely reflects that these indicators, derived from raw scores, are expected to be low in youth with intellectual disability, thereby limiting the validity of standard cutoffs in this population. Conclusions: The current review highlights that pediatric intellectual disability should not be presumed to invalidate performance validity testing. Second, stand-alone PVTs appear to represent the most defensible and clinically useful approach to response validity assessment in this population. Third, embedded indicators should be interpreted cautiously and never used in isolation to infer non-credible responding. Collectively, these findings support routine inclusion of developmentally appropriate, culturally informed stand-alone validity testing in pediatric neuropsychological and forensic evaluations to reduce diagnostic error and strengthen interpretive confidence.