Performance and Symptom Validity Testing: Terminology, Conceptualization, Practice Standards, and Future Directions
Abstract
This commentary summarizes terminology and practice standards for assessing the validity of test scores obtained during neuropsychological evaluations. It also highlights conceptual gaps and emerging directions for improving validity assessment. The process of assessing the accuracy and interpretability of psychometric test scores is foundational to neuropsychology. However, terminology used to communicate these findings requires conceptual refinement to align with evolving practice standards and advances in psychometric theory. Such terminology must also reflect that validity problems are not reduced to poor effort or volitional exaggeration. Validity is a broader interpretive concern that applies to all practicing neuropsychologists, who must distinguish between presumed causes and patterns of invalidity, while also considering the intended use of scores relative to the patient and context. Symptom- and performance-based scores serve different interpretive purposes, and their validity should be evaluated separately. The strongest validity determinations are based on converging evidence across multiple complementary psychometric- and clinically-based indicators, with attention to base rates of invalid responding and genuinely low scores. Digital technologies may help the field keep pace with evolving standards and conceptual developments. Technologies can improve validity assessment by capturing more data, analyzing it with advanced algorithms, and doing so in ways that are more accessible for patients and efficient for clinicians. However, neuropsychologists must remain stewards of these digital methods, ensuring their development and use preserve clinical nuance, empirical rigor, and ethical standards. Used appropriately, digital tools may complement rather than replace the uniquely human aspects of validity assessment. Performance and symptom validity assessment is an evidence-based process used to determine whether neuropsychological test findings accurately reflect a person’s cognitive abilities or symptomatic experiences. However, terminology in this area has often been used inconsistently, blurring important distinctions among what validity measures assess, what invalid responding implies, and the factors that contribute to invalid responding. In this article, we clarify these distinctions by reviewing terminology used to describe validity assessment methods, patterns of invalid responding, and factors that may threaten validity. We then summarize best-practice standards for performance and symptom validity assessment, emphasizing the use of multiple psychometric and clinically based indicators to estimate the extent to which test scores reflect the constructs they are intended to represent. We explain why such validity findings must be interpreted in relation to the individual, the referral question, and the evaluation context, rather than being treated as sole or direct indicators of noncredible responding or its presumed causes. Finally, we explain how emerging technologies may improve this assessment process by capturing and analyzing additional information underlying a person’s invalid responses. We further describe how such technologies may help distinguish between the presence and appearance of invalid responding and its presumed causes. Ultimately, we contend that, as long as neuropsychologists remain stewards of these innovations, digital technologies can improve validity assessment while preserving the central role of clinical judgment.