Skip to content
Open access

How are commercial determinants of health problematised in key health and climate policy guidance?

Oct 2026 · European Journal of Public Health · Vol 36 · 0 citations

Abstract

Abstract Background Commercial forces impact health and climate outcomes. Given the need for coherent policy approaches, we critically examine the problematisation of commercial activities in documents guiding the development of multisectoral climate and health policies. This guidance matters: it informs how governments set their climate and health policies, and thus the health of their populations. Methods A qualitative content analysis of documents published by the World Health Organization, United Nations Environment Programme and the UK Government between 2014 and 2025 to guide multisectoral action for climate and health, to understand how they problematise commercial actors, products and practices in their a) policy background, b) proposed policy solutions and c) approaches to governance. Results Policy guidance documents (n = 25) were more likely to ‘passively’ problematise commercial products (mostly fossil fuels) as harmful to climate and health, than to ‘actively’ attribute these products to specific commercial actors, practices, or policy solutions. Policy solutions prioritised downstream interventions in the health care sector, interventions that emphasised behaviour change and product-shifting, or interventions that advocated a role for a largely undifferentiated ‘private sector’ to deliver and finance policy. Despite some upstream attention to fiscal measures, such as taxes and subsidies towards fossil fuels and carbon-intensive agriculture, several key commercial determinants of health and climate change were not problematised. These included policy solutions for commercial tax avoidance, fossil fuel advertising, and jointly state- and corporate-owned high-emitting enterprises. Conclusions Existing health and climate policy guidance is widely neglecting structural, consumptogenic and commercial drivers of harm. Instead, by prioritising interventions in the health care sector, guidance risks performing a narrow, biomedical policy paradigm for climate and health. Key messages • Existing guidance for developing health and climate policies widely fails to engage with structural, consumptogenic and commercial drivers of harm, except for partial attention to fiscal measures. • Guidance prioritises policy solutions within the health care sector. No guidance problematises policy responses to commercial tax avoidance, fossil fuel advertising, or state-owned enterprises.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

The challenges of using upstream policy instruments to reduce health inequalities: a qualitative study in the UK

In the UK, local government public health departments have responsibilities for health inequalities in their populations. Addressing these is an enduring challenge, given that the determinants of health equity lie in other sectors. A central government programme, Levelling Up, provided funds for action related to...

Fiona Ward, Matilda Attrill, Judith Green et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Local authority responses to climate and health impacts: policy analysis across four England regions

Abstract Background Climate change poses increasing risks to population health, including heat-related illness, flooding, poor air quality and disruption to essential services. In England, local authorities influence key determinants of climate-related health through responsibilities for housing, transport, environment...

G. Turner, L. O'Connor, E. O'Connell et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

O.4. Scientific session: Working to address commercial determinants of health at local government level: Emerging findings

Abstract   Commercial actors play a vital role in society, yet there is growing evidence that some of their products and practices contribute to avoidable ill health, environmental damage and widening inequalities. These dynamics are increasingly conceptualised as the commercial determinants of health (CDoH), defined a...

A. Gilmore · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Health, climate change and vulnerability: a policy analysis of three high-income European countries

Abstract Background Europe is the fastest‑warming continent, with climate change increasingly affecting population health. These impacts are unevenly distributed, disproportionately affecting vulnerable populations. Yet, it remains unclear how health‑related vulnerability and justice are operationalized in climate adap...

I. Budin-Ljøsne, Z. Sangalli, B. Detering et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

O.6. Practice session: How commercial determinants and conflicts of interest affect health: fossil fuels & infant formula

Abstract Background Commercial determinants of health (CDoH) increasingly shape population health outcomes but remain insufficiently integrated into public health practice. Fossil fuel and infant formula industries illustrate how commercial actors not only generate harmful exposures but also actively shape how health r...

F. Tahzib, Angela Giusti · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Investing in health equity: A health impact assessment on the 2024 Irish Climate Action Plan

Abstract Background Climate change is a major determinant of health. The Irish government, like many governments, is tackling climate change through strategic climate action policy planning. This research study examined the process of undertaking a health impact assessment (HIA) of the 2024 Climate Action Plan’s measur...

M. O'Mullane, T. Kenny, M. Brennan et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.