What works for whom? A systematic mapping review of psychological treatments for adults with longstanding anorexia nervosa
Abstract
ABSTRACT Adults with longstanding anorexia nervosa (AN) present with diverse needs and variable responses to established interventions. While evidence-based treatments remain central to practice, outcomes are often modest, and relapse risk remains significant. Emerging therapies such as Dialectical Behaviour Therapy for Multi-Diagnostic Eating Disorders (MED-DBT) may address pervasive difficulties with emotion regulation and complexity commonly present for people who have not responded to first-line treatments; however, the diversity of treatments and limited empirical base make direct comparison challenging. We searched PsycINFO, MEDLINE, CINAHL, and Embase for studies published between 2005 and 2025 of psychological interventions for adults with longstanding AN. Any quantitative interventional design was included. Due to heterogeneity in study design, population definitions, and outcome measurements, a narrative mapping synthesis of models, treatment targets, and outcomes was completed rather than a quantitative comparison. Sixteen primary studies, predominantly case series and uncontrolled cohort study designs, were included. Across modalities, BMI and ED psychopathology frequently improved at post-intervention with mixed maintenance at follow-up, while general psychopathology showed inconsistent change. Results indicate that psychological treatments for longstanding AN are diverse, frequently integrative, and variably reported. Mapping models to treatment targets and maintaining factors may better support treatment matching than assuming interchangeability among “evidence-based” labels. Rigorous, adequately powered studies using consistent definitions, outcomes, and follow-up timepoints are needed to support confident, evidence-based recommendations.