Comparative Analysis of Classical vs Quantum Secret Sharing Schemes
Abstract
The fundamental concepts, safety guarantees, efficiency, and applicability to real-world cryptographic applications of both classical and quantum secret sharing techniques are carefully discussed in this work. Shamir’s and Blakley’s schemes are examples of CSS schemes that for long have provided information-theoretic security for sharing secrets among multiple parties such that only authorized subsets are able to retrieve the secret. However, in the post-quantum era, these systems inherently have a vulnerability to quantum computational attacks due to the fact that they rely exclusively on classical communication. This paper assesses trade-offs between classical efficiency and quantum-level security by closely examining their methodologies, security models, and resource requirements. Furthermore, it discusses practical issues, such as decoherence, quantum memory constraints, and channel authentication, that present significant challenges in the implementation of QSS. By making a comparison between these two paradigms, we identify the contexts in which each approach is particularly suitable, and thus point to possible hybrid frameworks combining the robustness of classical cryptography with quantum security. These comparisons provide new insights for designing next-generation cryptographic protocols in emerging quantum technologies.