Forensic source classes and toxic-equivalent concentrations of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in soils and sediments: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Abstract
Diagnostic-ratio source attribution is routine in environmental forensics, but whether the assigned source class predicts the benzo[a]pyrene toxic-equivalent concentration (TEQBaP) of a contaminated solid matrix has not been evaluated quantitatively. We conducted a systematic review (PRISMA 2020) of soil and sediment studies published from 2013 to 2026 that reported TEQBaP together with a diagnostic-ratio source classification. A structured search of Scopus, PubMed, and Web of Science conducted on 2 July 2026 returned 2,119 records, which were reduced through successive screening to a review corpus of 105 full texts; with a supplementary search, 67 studies were included in the review. A total of 16 studies met the quantitative criteria after a primary-source audit of every extracted value, of which 12 yielded a directly derivable sampling variance (primary model) and 14 yielded a variance with imputation. The outcome was the reported BaP-equivalent concentration, a carcinogenic-potency metric, not a measured biological effect. ln(TEQBaP) was pooled by restricted maximum likelihood with Hartung–Knapp–Sidik–Jonkman intervals. The pooled TEQBaP was 104.2 ng g -1 (95% CI = 32.4–335.6; k = 12), essentially unchanged under DerSimonian–Laird, Paule–Mandel, and equal weighting, with τ 2 = 3.27 (95% CI = 1.58–9.44), I 2 = 99.9%, and a 95% prediction interval of 1.6–6,942 ng g -1 . Pyrogenic and mixed assemblages differed by a factor of 0.57 (95% CI = 0.04–8.0; p = 0.639): no difference was detected, but the interval is compatible with anything from a substantial decrease to a roughly 20-fold increase, so this is an absence of detected association rather than evidence of equivalence. Petrogenic evidence remained insufficient for class-level inference (k = 3 overall; k = 1 in the primary model) even after the search was widened. Secondary moderators, including sampling environment, are reported as exploratory and hypothesis-generating only. A concentration-normalized mixture potency factor (MPF = TEQBaP/ΣPAH) is proposed as a reporting convention and evaluated as exploratory feasibility work; it remains unvalidated. The principal finding is that the available study-level evidence is too sparse and too heterogeneous to determine whether forensic source class predicts toxic-equivalent concentration—an evidence gap, not a demonstrated null.