Survey on Key Performance Indicators for Evaluating the Impact of Autonomous and Connected Vehicles on Traffic Flows and Mobility Services

Abstract

The introduction of Connected and Autonomous Vehicles (CAVs) into the existing traffic system represents one of the greatest challenges of modern road traffic engineering. Beyond their role as active traffic participants, CAVs can also be regarded as mobile (floating) sensors, effectively turning the vehicle fleet itself into a distributed, city-wide and motorway-wide sensing infrastructure. The transition from fully human-driven vehicles to fully autonomous vehicles will take decades, giving rise to a prolonged mixed-traffic period in which vehicles with different levels of automation share the same road space. This paper analyses the parameters and measures used for evaluating the throughput, environmental impact, and safety of traffic networks at different CAV penetration rates. It further reviews studies that rely exclusively on data collected from CAVs acting as mobile sensors, examining data-aggregation and traffic-state-estimation methods used to reconstruct macroscopic traffic parameters such as flow, density, headway, and speed. Additionally, measures for evaluating specific use cases for CAVs including mobility-on-demand services and their cost comparison with human-driven taxi operations are also addressed. The energy and emissions implications of CAV deployment, including the added burden of sensing hardware and system-level rebound effects, are also examined. Based on the synthesis performed, a set of representative CAVs penetration rates is proposed as a standardised framework for future mixed-traffic flow evaluations.