Skip to content
Review Open access

Expected clinical and patient-centered outcomes associated with different rehabilitation strategies for severe maxillary atrophy: an international cross-sectional survey

Giulio Gasparini M. Todaro Edoardo Papa M. Amato P. De Angelis A. Moro C. Lajolo Gianluca Nicolai E. Rella Roberto Boniello Xavier Moix Gil E. Staderini Sofia Gasparini F. Perquoti Gianmarco Spinozzi V. Santoro D. di Carlo Giuliano Ascani P. F. Manicone M. Foresti M. Perugini Francesca Azzuni M. Bertolini C. S. Moreira S. Barootchi Ryan A. Dunlop Guo-Hao Lin V. Broumand Felipe Kornecki Radzinski E. Alaaddinoğlu Alperen Kalyouncu S. Isler Yi-Qun Wu Simon Oh Rıdvan Güler Onur Şahin E. Ozgur Sascha Heinemann Michael M. Bornstein E. Couso-Queiruga C. Raabe Andrea Roccuzzo D. Thoma Y. Man Farah Asa'ad M. Sjöström Jae-Kook Cha M. Abram N. Redko A. Drobyshev E. Kharazyan C. Paoleschi Sadesh Kumar A. Trokhalin I. Bozo Z. Fábián Dragan Eliza M. Leretter Fernando Duarte A. Nowicki Ilaria Vitali J. Schortinghuis J. Pijpe G. Raghoebar M. Micunovic Viorica Chetrus A. Puišys Mohammad Ibrahim Alghraisi Stefan Cocis Rocco Borrello A. Paccagnella L. Catarzi G. Cirignaco A. Ciolfi T. Starch-Jensen H. Aludden Paolo Ricci Stefania Romano Stefano Negrini V. del Deo G. Consorti R. Girotto Roberto Rossi Igor Kaplasky F. A. Govoni R. Pistilli G. Isola Andrea Balercia E. Brauner S. Sivolella G. Colapinto Adaia Valls-Ontañón A. Jorba-García O. Camps-Font A. Khoshzaban A. Zupi A. Gaggl A. Chaux A. Bär B. Al-Nawas A. Mancini A. Scarano C. Van den Borre C. Alberti C. Steiner G. Bottini C. Debortoli E. Borie Eduardo Montero E. Qorri E. Silva G. Romito Farhan Durrani F. Sim F. Beck G. Baima J. Tunkel Henning Wieker Hendrik Terheyeden Kunaal Dhingra Liang-Zhi Du L. Vaira M. Nilius M. Kunrath Mariam Ahmed Roshdy M. Antal Gregorio Redaelli M. Elgamal Mohamed T. Khater Mohammed A. El-Sawy Mohammed Samir Ning-Bo Zhao P. Carosi Gaurav Tripathi Hamoun Sabri Hom-Lay Wang G. Saponaro
Sep 2026 · Frontiers in Oral Health · Vol 7 · 0 citations · 32 references
Medicine

Abstract

Background Severe maxillary atrophy remains one of the most challenging conditions in implant dentistry and maxillofacial surgery. Multiple rehabilitation strategies are currently available, including regenerative procedures, alternative implant-based approaches, and hybrid concepts. Although clinical outcomes have been widely reported, limited information exists regarding clinician-reported expectations associated with different rehabilitation strategies when evaluating the same clinical scenario. The aim of this study was to investigate clinician-reported expectations associated with different rehabilitation approaches for severe maxillary atrophy. Materials and methods An international cross-sectional survey was conducted using a standardized anonymized CBCT case classified as Cawood and Howell Class VI. The questionnaire was distributed through professional and academic networks between July and November 2025. Respondents with experience in at least five complex implant-prosthetic rehabilitations per year were included. After selecting their preferred rehabilitation strategy, participants completed a branching questionnaire exploring clinician-reported expectations regarding safety, predictability, immediate loading, implant survival, treatment duration, smile satisfaction, masticatory function, oral hygiene and maintainability, postoperative morbidity, annual maintenance costs, patient satisfaction, and quality-of-life improvement. Descriptive statistics were performed. Results A total of 155 eligible clinicians from 33 countries were included. Alternative implant-based strategies were selected by 83 respondents (53.5%), regenerative approaches by 45 (29.0%), and hybrid approaches by 27 (17.4%). Clinicians selecting alternative implant-based strategies more frequently anticipated immediate loading (81.9%), functional rehabilitation within 72 h (83.1%), and implant survival exceeding 95% at five years (57.8%). Respondents selecting regenerative approaches more commonly expected treatment durations of approximately one year (64.4%) and reported highly favorable expectations regarding smile satisfaction (86.7%), patient satisfaction (82.2%), and quality-of-life improvement (97.8%). Across all therapeutic preference groups, clinician-reported expectations regarding masticatory function, patient satisfaction, and quality-of-life improvement were generally favorable. Most respondents anticipated postoperative discomfort lasting between one and four weeks and treatment abandonment rates below 5%. Conclusions Clinicians selecting different rehabilitation strategies for severe maxillary atrophy reported distinct expectations regarding treatment timing, predictability, implant survival, aesthetics, maintenance requirements, morbidity, and patient-centered outcomes. Despite these differences, expectations were generally favorable across all therapeutic preference groups, suggesting that multiple rehabilitation pathways are currently perceived as viable treatment options. The findings should be interpreted as clinician-reported expectations rather than direct measurements of clinical or patient-reported outcomes.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.