Implementing OSCEs in medical schools across Sub-Saharan Africa: a scoping review.
Abstract
Background
The Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) is widely recognised as a valid method for assessing clinical competence in medical education. However, its implementation in Sub-Saharan African (SSA) medical schools presents distinct challenges. This scoping review synthesises current evidence on the barriers and facilitators influencing OSCE delivery in undergraduate medical education across the region and identifies strategies to strengthen its implementation.
Methods
A comprehensive search of PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, and CINAHL for studies published between 2010 and 2025 yielded 292 studies. Twelve eligible studies were included and charted using a structured data extraction framework. Thematic synthesis guided the analysis, with findings mapped to student and examiner perspectives on OSCE implementation.
Results
Resource constraints, including limited simulation equipment, inadequate physical space, and insufficient numbers of trained examiners were the most consistently reported barriers. Students frequently described anxiety, unfamiliarity with the OSCE format, and inadequate preparation as impediments to optimal performance. Conversely, both students and examiners perceived OSCEs as fair, objective, and comprehensive assessments. Facilitators included the use of structured checklists, mock OSCEs, supportive examiner behaviour, and institutional investment in simulation and assessment infrastructure. Across studies, recommended actions focused on enhancing student preparation, expanding faculty development, refining OSCE station design, strengthening logistical planning, and incorporating routine quality assurance practises such as psychometric evaluation.
Conclusion
OSCEs hold substantial potential for strengthening competency-based assessment in SSA medical education; however, their effectiveness is closely tied to institutional capacity and educational system readiness. Addressing resource limitations, improving examiner training, expanding simulation-based learning, and embedding robust quality assurance processes are essential steps towards sustainable OSCE implementation. Continued research and policy support are needed to optimise OSCE integration within the region's evolving medical education landscape.