B-173: Threats to Objectivity in Forensic Neuropsychology: A Framework for Understanding Cognitive, Adversarial, Emotional, and Technological Influences on Clinical Decision-Making
Abstract
Objective: Forensic neuropsychological evaluations are conducted within adversarial legal systems in which clinicians produce scientifically grounded opinions under conditions of heightened scrutiny, competing expert interpretations, and high-stakes legal outcomes. Although professional guidelines emphasize objectivity and neutrality, translating complex neuropsychological data into defensible forensic opinions inherently involves clinical judgment, increasing vulnerability to bias. Existing literature has identified multiple sources of bias in forensic practice, including cognitive heuristics, adversarial allegiance, and emotional influences; however, these factors are often examined in isolation and lack integration into a clinically applicable framework specific to forensic neuropsychological decision-making. Method/Data Selection: A narrative review of empirical literature across cognitive psychology, bias research, forensic practice, and human factors was conducted, focusing on sources addressing cognitive bias, adversarial influences, emotional processes, and emerging technological factors relevant to forensic neuropsychological evaluations. Results/Data Synthesis: This review integrates four domains of threats to objectivity: (1) cognitive biases in interpretation and hypothesis testing under ambiguity; (2) adversarial pressures, including retaining-party effects and competing expert dynamics; (3) emotional and interpersonal influences, including countertransference and exposure to high-stakes material; and (4) technological influences, including artificial intelligence-assisted scoring, interpretation, and report drafting. These factors may interact across evaluation stages. Artificial intelligence may introduce automation bias and reduced vigilance while creating an illusion of objectivity. Conclusions: Integrating these domains provides a clinically relevant framework for understanding bias in forensic neuropsychological evaluations. Emphasis on structured reasoning, transparency, bias monitoring, and critical appraisal of artificial intelligence outputs may support maintenance of scientific neutrality in high-stakes legal contexts.